WMA 5.1 in WMV decodes to stereo - Page 2

desc · 2007-05-30, 11:31

I've just started encountering this too.

I cannot get GraphEdit to display what is happening when WMP plays back the WMV BUT AC3 Filter is loaded and being used.

When I playback the same file, AC3 filter is NOT loaded and using GraphEdit I can see that "WMAudio Decoder DMO" is being used.

I have AC3 Filter setup as the Audio Codec in MP but it makes no difference to WMV playback

dman_lfc · 2007-05-30, 12:08

AC3 filter afaik is not pin compatible with the WMV audio streams this is your problem. It will default to the highest merit compatible codec in this case WMAudio Decoder DMO.
From recollection FFDShow provides a compatible decoder for 5.1 WMV playback.

DMAN

desc · 2007-05-30, 13:02

If that is/was true then why would I see AC3Filter being loaded and used by Windows MediaPlayer (WMP) ?

I have attached 2 screendumps from GraphEdit to show what is happening.

GraphEdit_RenderMediaFile.jpg shows the graph that is used when I ask GraphEdit to render a 720p 6Channel WMV file.

MediaPortal_PlayBack_6chWMV.jpg is the output of getting GraphEdit to open a remote graph. In this case MediaPortal is playing back the same 720p 6ch WMV file.

As you can see, when MP is playing back the file it bypasses the AC3Filter (and only renders 2ch Stereo sound).

FWIW, MediaPlayer Classic generates a similar graph to WindowsMedia Player; except that MPC uses VMR9 for video output.

EVH999 · 2007-07-04, 20:37

I've been trying for weeks to figure out why I cannot get 5.1 sound on WMV files as well. Does nayone have any idea how to fix this. We tried to compile the code posted in one of the threads in C++ with no luck. Someone muct have an answer to this.

petsta · 2007-07-07, 17:57

I'm having the exact same problem as described here and have also made the analysis with GraphEdit showing that AC3Filter is included in the filter chain when WMP or almost any other player is used. However when MP is used AC3Filter is not included in the chain.

I also did som further testing an started MP and used GraphEdit to connect to the remote Graph. Then I manually added AC3Filter to the filter vhain and started plaing the movie again and suddendly the audio was going via AC3Filter and 5.1 AC3 sound was perfect.

Regards,

Peter

EVH999 · 2007-07-07, 18:37

So is there a way to make it work without using GraphEdit?

ltfearme · 2007-07-07, 22:55

I think someone should raise a bug on this so the developers are aware.

Damien

phunqe · 2007-07-25, 00:40

Please report your problem here http://forum.team-mediaportal.com/wm...ng-t25907.html so we can get some attention on this.

rav994 · 2007-10-08, 21:52

Anny one have a sollution for this?

JonL · 2007-10-11, 03:01

I have same issues with MP3 and AAC. MCE/WMPlayer output 5.1 digital to my receiver (I get the Dolby indicator), but the same files are in analog stereo (no Dolby indicator). I use ffdshow for AAC and AC3Filter for everything else (NVIDIA SPDIF for DVDs).

2007-05-30, 12:08	#12 (permalink)
dman_lfc Portal Manager Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: UK Posts: 1,635 Thanks: 0 Thanked 21 Times in 17 Posts Country: My System	AC3 filter afaik is not pin compatible with the WMV audio streams this is your problem. It will default to the highest merit compatible codec in this case WMAudio Decoder DMO. From recollection FFDShow provides a compatible decoder for 5.1 WMV playback. DMAN __________________ Hardware: Core2 Duo 3.0GHz, Nvidia 8500GS (256MB), 1GB DDR2, Intel DG33TL MB, 2x FireDTV DVB-S2 cards & Nova 500-T in a Antec Fusion case with VFD & iMon remote. Software: Windows XP MCE2005, PureVideo codecs & Cyberlink PowerDVD 7.x codecs.

2007-05-30, 13:02	#13 (permalink)
desc Portal User Join Date: May 2007 Age: 31 Posts: 3 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country:	If that is/was true then why would I see AC3Filter being loaded and used by Windows MediaPlayer (WMP) ? I have attached 2 screendumps from GraphEdit to show what is happening. GraphEdit_RenderMediaFile.jpg shows the graph that is used when I ask GraphEdit to render a 720p 6Channel WMV file. MediaPortal_PlayBack_6chWMV.jpg is the output of getting GraphEdit to open a remote graph. In this case MediaPortal is playing back the same 720p 6ch WMV file. As you can see, when MP is playing back the file it bypasses the AC3Filter (and only renders 2ch Stereo sound). FWIW, MediaPlayer Classic generates a similar graph to WindowsMedia Player; except that MPC uses VMR9 for video output. Attached Thumbnails Last edited by desc; 2007-05-30 at 13:37. Reason: Attaching Screenshots

2007-07-25, 00:40	#18 (permalink)
phunqe Portal Member Join Date: Apr 2007 Posts: 222 Thanks: 6 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts	Please report your problem here http://forum.team-mediaportal.com/wm...ng-t25907.html so we can get some attention on this. Last edited by phunqe; 2007-07-25 at 01:10.

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
AverTV Purity-3D Dual MCE 500 Drivers	Technifide	General Support	10	2006-10-17 14:54
Pinnacle PCTV Stereo recognized as 2 cards ? setup crashes	Redguy	General Support	2	2006-08-15 12:22
Switch between AC3 and stereo	Johan	General Support	0	2006-04-25 08:07
RC3: AC3 sound vs. Stereo	Uli321	The old Bugreport Forum	2	2006-04-09 17:26
AC3 Filter - stereo to 5.1 works in WMP not Gspot or Graph	irrotational	OffTopic	2	2005-10-18 14:57

2007-05-30, 11:31	#11 (permalink)
desc Portal User Join Date: May 2007 Age: 31 Posts: 3 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country:	I've just started encountering this too. I cannot get GraphEdit to display what is happening when WMP plays back the WMV BUT AC3 Filter is loaded and being used. When I playback the same file, AC3 filter is NOT loaded and using GraphEdit I can see that "WMAudio Decoder DMO" is being used. I have AC3 Filter setup as the Audio Codec in MP but it makes no difference to WMV playback

2007-07-04, 20:37	#14 (permalink)
EVH999 Portal Member Join Date: Nov 2006 Posts: 13 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts	I've been trying for weeks to figure out why I cannot get 5.1 sound on WMV files as well. Does nayone have any idea how to fix this. We tried to compile the code posted in one of the threads in C++ with no luck. Someone muct have an answer to this.

2007-07-07, 17:57	#15 (permalink)
petsta Portal User Join Date: Jul 2007 Posts: 2 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country:	I'm having the exact same problem as described here and have also made the analysis with GraphEdit showing that AC3Filter is included in the filter chain when WMP or almost any other player is used. However when MP is used AC3Filter is not included in the chain. I also did som further testing an started MP and used GraphEdit to connect to the remote Graph. Then I manually added AC3Filter to the filter vhain and started plaing the movie again and suddendly the audio was going via AC3Filter and 5.1 AC3 sound was perfect. Regards, Peter

2007-07-07, 18:37	#16 (permalink)
EVH999 Portal Member Join Date: Nov 2006 Posts: 13 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts	So is there a way to make it work without using GraphEdit?

2007-07-07, 22:55	#17 (permalink)
ltfearme Portal Member Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Sydney Posts: 341 Thanks: 30 Thanked 27 Times in 24 Posts Country: My System	I think someone should raise a bug on this so the developers are aware. Damien

2007-10-08, 21:52	#19 (permalink)
rav994 Portal Member Join Date: Jun 2007 Age: 34 Posts: 17 Thanks: 0 Thanked 1 Time in 1 Post Country:	Anny one have a sollution for this?

2007-10-11, 03:01	#20 (permalink)
JonL Portal Member Join Date: Oct 2007 Posts: 9 Thanks: 2 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country:	I have same issues with MP3 and AAC. MCE/WMPlayer output 5.1 digital to my receiver (I get the Dolby indicator), but the same files are in analog stereo (no Dolby indicator). I use ffdshow for AAC and AC3Filter for everything else (NVIDIA SPDIF for DVDs).