5sec to open a .ts file with TsReader (another reason for Vista, NO Respondig Window)

[iosub]

Hi

This is a continuation of the 8 sec delay for Directsound!!?

Also another delay... 5sec on
TsReaderPlayer.cs on line 410
hr = interfaceFile.Load(filename, null);
If the file is rtsp:\\ it takes only less 1sec but if the file is R:\MediaShift\live4-0.ts.tsbuffer it takes 5SEC!!...

Check TsReader.log
16-05-2008 00:39:05.539 [ef8]-------------- v1.0.3 ----------------
16-05-2008 00:39:05.541 [ef8]CTsReaderFilter::ctor
16-05-2008 00:39:05.543 [ef8]CRTSPClient::Initialize()
16-05-2008 00:39:05.544 [ef8]CRTSPClient::createClient()
16-05-2008 00:39:05.546 [ef8]CALLBACK SET
16-05-2008 00:39:05.547 [ef8]SetRequestAudioChangeCallback SET
16-05-2008 00:39:05.555 [ef8]CTsReaderFilter::Load()
16-05-2008 00:39:07.966 [ef8]FileReader::CloseFile() no open file
16-05-2008 00:39:09.090 [ef8]OnNewChannel pat version:-1->1
16-05-2008 00:39:09.092 [ef8]demux:flushing


I think that if we speed up these issues... "we will fix the No responding...."


Anything else I can do...??

Iosu

[Marcusb]

io, with all the work you do looking into these things, are you actually a programmer or just a kind of fiddler?
I've seen a lot of these type of messages from you and you seem to really be good at getting to the small details of a problem.

Please take no offense with the "fiddler" question. That's kind of what I am to a small extent

Anyway, just wanted to say thanks for your efforts and I hope a dev can look into this and run with it.

Marcus.

[tourettes]

RTPS handling the TsReader is just slow (not sure if it can be speed up in any easy way). Like I said in the different post related to the "program not responding" issue, MP design is causing the issue. There are probably hundreds of places in the code that can trigger it. Of course every small delay that we get of the MP code base is improving the user experience, but someone should fix the actual issue

EDIT: that might have sounded a little bit harsh, that wasnt my intention. Even getting one small delay might improve the user experience a lot, but the real problem still stays there, no matter how well we try to hide it

[iosub]

Originally Posted by tourettes

RTPS handling the TsReader is just slow (not sure if it can be speed up in any easy way). Like I said in the different post related to the "program not responding" issue, MP design is causing the issue. There are probably hundreds of places in the code that can trigger it. Of course every small delay that we get of the MP code base is improving the user experience, but someone should fix the actual issue

EDIT: that might have sounded a little bit harsh, that wasnt my intention. Even getting one small delay might improve the user experience a lot, but the real problem still stays there, no matter how well we try to hide it

RTPS is going fast less that 1 sec, when Opening a file "r:\...." is going slow..

Iosu

Originally Posted by Marcusb

io, with all the work you do looking into these things, are you actually a programmer or just a kind of fiddler?
I've seen a lot of these type of messages from you and you seem to really be good at getting to the small details of a problem.

Please take no offense with the "fiddler" question. That's kind of what I am to a small extent

Anyway, just wanted to say thanks for your efforts and I hope a dev can look into this and run with it.

Marcus.

jajaj, yes I'm a programer, 25 year on bussines... (actualy now I run the bussines so I'm just playing now with MP)
I have my own company of 20 programers here is spain.. Also I was a Ms employee (but please don't say that to others ) :-)

Iosu

[iosub]

Tourettes: Any change to speed up TSreader when opening a files like when Opening a file "r:\...." , maybe if you open the file as readonly???

Thanks

[Swede]

If R: is on another computer, try to use \\computername\drive... (you know) instead.

[iosub]

Yes, I try that allready... No luck :-(

There is something there that I have to find... Or yoy, good finder!! :-)

You find I fix :-)

Thanks Iosu

[Swede]

It's not a sleeping drive or DMA? Sometimes it's the simplest things... For me it seems to start/stop a little bit to slow with the movies that are on the same drive as MP, so I get a short "No responding" there.

[iosub]

Yes, but the log you posted was using and .avi file, so no Tsreader involved.. My problem is with .ts files

What codec are you using for .avi files?

Iosu

[Swede]

Latest ffdshow tryouts. Not the problem, since films on other drives are fast. For .ts files I use microsofts own in Vista

What I meant could slow it down was that MP is working with the HD (database actions, log writing and things) at the same time as the .avi or .ts file is loading, and when all is on the same HD, it takes twize the time.

But you allready know that

Btw, your patch is still working perfectly