avi multiple audio/subtitle streams fix in version 0.1.3.0?

2005-06-29, 15:28

i've been wanting to post that awhile back.

why does no one care about being able to switch audio/subtitle streams in avi containers?!?

the only media center that is capable of doing that is meedio, which generally sucks because of its user interface...

it's the only thing about mediaportal that drives me nuts, since i think it should've been implemented from the start.

is there any information on when it might be implemented?

i've dozens of avis with 2 audio streams and 1 subtitle file, i encoded only a few of them.

thanks for input.

-pedah

igalan · 2005-06-30, 11:02

I subscribe this feature request. Often I encode AVIs with two audio tracks (with VirtualDub Mod). Right now both tracks get mixed up

.

2005-06-30, 22:07

I used to have this problem and my solution was to uninstall ffdshow even though it's heavily recommended for MP as the primary codec. I installed the "K-Lite Codec Pack 2.45" and it's worked perfectly ever since. I think that codec installer contains the morgan stream switcher which fixes the problem.

igalan · 2005-07-01, 10:00

I'll have a look at this, because after installing ffdshow, the DivX player no longer works

. And it does a better job at playing movies than Winamp 5 does. Anyway I already had installed Xvid 1.0.3 and DivX 5.2.1, so I don't think I need ffdshow.

2005-07-04, 11:49

i wanna be able to switch between audio/subtitle streams.

there's a morgan stream switcher solution by the matroska team, which coded some extra lines into the original one, which gave mp10 the feature of switching between audio and subtitle streams in a context menu.

the strange thing is that this filter doesn't work with mediaportal at all.

i still don't understand why the mediaportal team didn't finish the media player part of their product first, including switching between streams.

it's a real shame that they are working on so many things at the same time and adding more and more features, instead of finishing one part and head over to the next.

as for the tv part. i'm not a fan of mixing tv and other media, unless the tv part is a seperate product which can funtion as a plugin.

there are several open source tv solutions on the market today. the best and most advanced of them is vdr by klaus schmidinger (www.cadsoft.de/vdr/), who spend five years of programming it, starting from scratch. he started implementing plugins and other features like skinning after his solution was considered stable and after tidying up his code.

long story short: mediaportal has so much potential, but its roadmap needs to be reorganized.

conclusion: there's still no media center software available that plays back all main video formats with their most commonly used features.

igalan · 2005-07-04, 12:04

So it's not only me. In the manual you can read that it's possible to switch audio streams and subtitles (Read here). But those options are unavailable for me. It least now I know that they haven't been implemented yet (as of 0.1.3 pre) :cry: .

Yuri · 2005-09-07, 09:34

I agree. Multiaudio and multi subtitle switching is important!
I have a lot of mkv files with dual audio and subs. Now, MediaPrtal only plays the 1st audio stream.

The features list says, it is capable to switch, but it is not. LOL

andinaegnaeg · 2005-09-07, 14:12

I'd like to push that post up again.

I would love be able to play Dual-Audio-Avi's !! As many people know the Morgan Multimedia Stream Switcher can do this in WMP9. I hope someone is gonna be willing to implement that function.

I'm not a pro but I hope it isn't that hard to make that function available in MP.

Thanks a lot!
Regards,
Andreas

patrick · 2005-09-07, 17:40

Maybe this is what you are looking for?

Check out this thread about the third post
from the bottom about codec config
http://nolanparty.com/mediaportal.so...pic.php?t=8677

There is a note in this thread that the codecs mentioned in the
last thread must be installed for it to work properly.
http://nolanparty.com/mediaportal.so...pic.php?t=8836

HTH,
patrick

Yuri · 2005-09-08, 11:32

I checked the latest version: Mediaportal_0.2.0_RC1.

Sub and audio switching is working great in mkv files!
But avi and ogm files; it plays both audio tracks and no subtitle switching.

Or my codecs are playing fun again? :?:

EDIT: Well not a big deal. I can always convert ogm and dual audio avi to mkv. :wink:

2005-06-29, 15:28	#1 (permalink)
pedah Guest Posts: n/a	avi multiple audio/subtitle streams fix in version 0.1.3.0? i've been wanting to post that awhile back. why does no one care about being able to switch audio/subtitle streams in avi containers?!? the only media center that is capable of doing that is meedio, which generally sucks because of its user interface... it's the only thing about mediaportal that drives me nuts, since i think it should've been implemented from the start. is there any information on when it might be implemented? i've dozens of avis with 2 audio streams and 1 subtitle file, i encoded only a few of them. thanks for input. -pedah

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
IPTV@UT Plugin	moiristo	Plugins	116	2008-10-06 22:32
XMMImporter	Hesse	Plugins	33	2008-06-07 23:33
Fusion HDTV5 Gold and external inputs	nst6563	General Support	7	2006-05-27 20:05
mp crahs while preparing for hibernation	fera	The old Bugreport Forum	25	2006-03-23 19:48
My Alarm	devo	Plugins	27	2004-09-28 03:14

2005-06-30, 11:02	#2 (permalink)
igalan Portal Developer Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Barcelona Age: 36 Posts: 334 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country: My System	I subscribe this feature request. Often I encode AVIs with two audio tracks (with VirtualDub Mod). Right now both tracks get mixed up .

2005-06-30, 22:07	#3 (permalink)
Anonymous Guest Posts: n/a	I used to have this problem and my solution was to uninstall ffdshow even though it's heavily recommended for MP as the primary codec. I installed the "K-Lite Codec Pack 2.45" and it's worked perfectly ever since. I think that codec installer contains the morgan stream switcher which fixes the problem.

2005-07-01, 10:00	#4 (permalink)
igalan Portal Developer Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Barcelona Age: 36 Posts: 334 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country: My System	I'll have a look at this, because after installing ffdshow, the DivX player no longer works . And it does a better job at playing movies than Winamp 5 does. Anyway I already had installed Xvid 1.0.3 and DivX 5.2.1, so I don't think I need ffdshow.

2005-07-04, 11:49	#5 (permalink)
pedah Guest Posts: n/a	i wanna be able to switch between audio/subtitle streams. there's a morgan stream switcher solution by the matroska team, which coded some extra lines into the original one, which gave mp10 the feature of switching between audio and subtitle streams in a context menu. the strange thing is that this filter doesn't work with mediaportal at all. i still don't understand why the mediaportal team didn't finish the media player part of their product first, including switching between streams. it's a real shame that they are working on so many things at the same time and adding more and more features, instead of finishing one part and head over to the next. as for the tv part. i'm not a fan of mixing tv and other media, unless the tv part is a seperate product which can funtion as a plugin. there are several open source tv solutions on the market today. the best and most advanced of them is vdr by klaus schmidinger (www.cadsoft.de/vdr/), who spend five years of programming it, starting from scratch. he started implementing plugins and other features like skinning after his solution was considered stable and after tidying up his code. long story short: mediaportal has so much potential, but its roadmap needs to be reorganized. conclusion: there's still no media center software available that plays back all main video formats with their most commonly used features.

2005-07-04, 12:04	#6 (permalink)
igalan Portal Developer Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: Barcelona Age: 36 Posts: 334 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country: My System	So it's not only me. In the manual you can read that it's possible to switch audio streams and subtitles (Read here). But those options are unavailable for me. It least now I know that they haven't been implemented yet (as of 0.1.3 pre) :cry: .

2005-09-07, 09:34	#7 (permalink)
Yuri Portal Member Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Hungary Age: 24 Posts: 14 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country: My System	I agree. Multiaudio and multi subtitle switching is important! I have a lot of mkv files with dual audio and subs. Now, MediaPrtal only plays the 1st audio stream. The features list says, it is capable to switch, but it is not. LOL

2005-09-07, 14:12	#8 (permalink)
andinaegnaeg Portal Member Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Kempten, Germany Posts: 41 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts	I'd like to push that post up again. I would love be able to play Dual-Audio-Avi's !! As many people know the Morgan Multimedia Stream Switcher can do this in WMP9. I hope someone is gonna be willing to implement that function. I'm not a pro but I hope it isn't that hard to make that function available in MP. Thanks a lot! Regards, Andreas

2005-09-07, 17:40	#9 (permalink)
patrick Portal Member Join Date: Apr 2005 Location: Southeast Age: 36 Posts: 606 Thanks: 6 Thanked 35 Times in 24 Posts Country:	Maybe this is what you are looking for? Check out this thread about the third post from the bottom about codec config http://nolanparty.com/mediaportal.so...pic.php?t=8677 There is a note in this thread that the codecs mentioned in the last thread must be installed for it to work properly. http://nolanparty.com/mediaportal.so...pic.php?t=8836 HTH, patrick

2005-09-08, 11:32	#10 (permalink)
Yuri Portal Member Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Hungary Age: 24 Posts: 14 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts Country: My System	I checked the latest version: Mediaportal_0.2.0_RC1. Sub and audio switching is working great in mkv files! But avi and ogm files; it plays both audio tracks and no subtitle switching. Or my codecs are playing fun again? :?: EDIT: Well not a big deal. I can always convert ogm and dual audio avi to mkv. :wink: