MadVR + LAV Filters, Perfect in MPC-BE, Bad in MP1 (1 Viewer)

TBacker

Portal Member
June 23, 2011
39
12
Home Country
United States of America United States of America
Country flag
With MP1 set for EVR + DRR + MPAR (my standard setup prior to trying madVR):

Windowed and full screen are exactly the same stats (shift+!):
  • Display: 1920x1080 @ 23.976
  • Measured Refresh Rate: ~23.975490
  • Render Time: 1.8 ms
So, madVR showing a different display mode between windowed and full screen does not happen in EVR (unless the display field in madVR stats means something different). And as demonstrated earlier, madVR does NOT show a different display mode in MPC-BE between windowed and full screen.

That's all the time I have today. Left it on my old EVR settings for now and will continue to mull this over.
 
Last edited:

joecrow

Test Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • August 9, 2012
    1,999
    1,419
    Home Country
    Germany Germany
    Country flag
    So no difference in CPU between MPC-BE and MP1. GPU difference was just 2-3%.

    Here is one thing I did notice:
    • In MPC-BE, in both windowed and full screen, madVR shows the display as 59.996 8 bit, RGB, limited
    • In MP1 windowed, madVR says display is 59.996 8 bit, RGB, limited
    • In MP1 full screen, madVR says display 23.9758 8 bit, RGB, limited

    For me as you may have seen in the earlier screenshots, there was a greater difference in GPU usage, over 10% but not sure if that is significant.
    I also noted differences between windowed and full screen modes, if for example I play a vid in MP with a refresh rate of 23 Madvr sets the display to 23hz for fullscreen but in windowed mode to 50hz (my default desktop refresh rate) but for me with MPC-BE playing the same vid it also set fullscreen to 23hz and windowed to 50hz. That seems to suggest that you may not have MPC-BE set up the same as MP.

    BTW is there a reason for using RGB limited, as I understand it Madvr works better with Full RGB. Also have you set up all possible "display modes" in the Madvr refresh rate changer and do you have MPs DRR disabled when using Madvr?
     
    Last edited:

    TBacker

    Portal Member
    June 23, 2011
    39
    12
    Home Country
    United States of America United States of America
    Country flag
    That seems to suggest that you may not have MPC-BE set up the same as MP.

    Not sure what could be different. MPE-BE is using the same LAV filters and madVR instances. All of it's internal filters are disabled. Would have to be something ancillary that I'm not thinking of.

    BTW is there a reason for using RGB limited, as I understand it Madvr works better with Full RGB. Also have you set up all possible "display modes" in the Madvr refresh rate changer and do you have MPs DRR disabled when using Madvr?

    The nVidia driver and madVR are both set to 0-255, so I don't know why it's insisting on staying in limited mode.

    Yes, disabling DRR is one of my steps when switching back and forth.

    I also quickly tried using MPAR vs LAV direct audio rendering this morning and it made no difference.

    I think at this point I am just going to live with EVR. I've spent a ton of time on this already and can't think of anything else to do. Whatever is causing the issue seems to be beyond configuration settings because I think I've hit about every permutation possible.
     
    Last edited:

    steven123

    Portal Member
    January 1, 2014
    16
    8
    46
    Home Country
    United Kingdom United Kingdom
    Country flag
    Just thought I would add to this thread as I have been playing with MadVR in MP1 recently.

    I have a very similar setup to Tbacker, but with an 8th gen i3 and a GTX 1660s.

    After playing with a lot of settings I found the best setup to be NGU (anti-alias) for chroma upscaling and ordered dithering. Jinc is basically the same as NGU. This gives a render time of about 12ms. If I set the dithering to error diffusion or use doubling for upscaling, the render time goes up to about 17ms. The image is still OK, however the GPU is working at about 70% and eventually all you can hear is the fan operating when the TV volume is down.

    The Good. For images with little motion, the image is very very good. Way better than EVR. However........

    The Bad. MadVR doesn't like motion. Whenever the image pans quickly or there is sudden movement, it judders. I have tried different motion settings, different upscaling, but all have the same result. Ironically it doesn't seem to be affected by sport. Watching cricket for example was fine.

    All this time I had been trying MadVR with MPAR. I just tried it with the audio renderer set to AV receiver with no change in quality.
     

    steven123

    Portal Member
    January 1, 2014
    16
    8
    46
    Home Country
    United Kingdom United Kingdom
    Country flag
    I thought I would give an update. I'm now on mediaportal 1.26 and madVR is working well. Render time is now about 7.5ms. I'm currently watching live Rugby and the motion is perfect. I can't say for share the upgrade to v1.26 has fixed it as nVidia have also given a number of driver updates. But the good news is it now works.
     

    CyberSimian

    Test Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • June 10, 2013
    2,347
    1,428
    Southampton
    Home Country
    United Kingdom United Kingdom
    Country flag
    Whenever the image pans quickly or there is sudden movement, it judders.
    I'm currently watching live Rugby and the motion is perfect.
    Recently I have been trying to reduce or eliminate juddering on my system. I notice it particularly with:
    • Horizontal panning (e.g. in travel or nature documentaries)
    • Horizontal "ticker tape" news feeds (e.g. "Sky News" channel)
    • Vertically scrolling programme credits (e.g. "Mock the Week")
    I originally had my Nvidia screen-config set to "1080p" (because "progressive" is generally regarded as being better than "interlaced"). But on a whim I changed it to "1080i", and noticed a significant reduction in juddering. However, there still is some juddering, albeit at a low level. :(

    My Sony TV exhibits no juddering at all when receiving the TV signal directly, and I would really like my HTPC to provide the same performance. I have not yet tried Madvr, so I am curious as to whether it now solves all of your juddering problems? Thank you.

    -- from CyberSimian in the UK
     

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Similar threads

    Hi @el Filou Ok I understand, that not easy :( So for now ReClock is the best :)
    Hi @el Filou Ok I understand, that not easy :( So for now ReClock is the best :)
    Description of Change This branch will permit to have madVR renderer to MP1, thanks to Tourettes for this and Madshi. This branch...
    Replies
    6K
    Views
    539K
    So I tried a few times futile on the client/laptop - no connection to the server... pesky firewall! - but eventually just installed ReClock on the HTPC. Followed your instructions and still no effect. (I haven't rebooted the HTPC yet, but I doubt it will help.) Pressing F10 during playback shows the same choppy curves as in my...
    So I tried a few times futile on the client/laptop - no connection to the server... pesky firewall! - but eventually just installed...
    I have been using MP1 for many years on my current hardware (old but worked well with MP1). I've now reformatted my HDD and...
    Replies
    13
    Views
    3K
    LAV in MP cannot use Default DirectSound device as renderer. LAV in wmp and MP-HC use LAV and Default DirectSound device as renderer without any problem. i'll post later today graphstudio picture
    LAV in MP cannot use Default DirectSound device as renderer. LAV in wmp and MP-HC use LAV and Default DirectSound device as...
    Hi guys, my current configuration is: MP: 1.14 PR (updated from 1.13 today to see if this problem is fixed in latest version) LAV...
    Replies
    4
    Views
    3K
    MP1 MP2 No AC3 sound ... DE
    @fanol Thanks for providing the log files. However they contain only limited detail. Could you please collect new log files, and this time use the Watchdog tool with option 1 or 2 ("report a bug...") to do it. The Watchdog tool is the preferred method/source for collecting log files. Please use it whenever you can. General...
    @fanol Thanks for providing the log files. However they contain only limited detail. Could you please collect new log files, and...
    Hi! I start to play, and there is no sound. Established LAV 0.68 everywhere. On the other formats and movies is no such problem. I...
    Replies
    84
    Views
    11K
    Tried with a custom LAV build from @Sebastiii (0.68.5 git) and got a bit further :) - Works with MPC-HC (no image corruption) as subtitle engine however no subtitle selection for that sample - With DirectVobSub I get the subtitle selection however also the image corruption back So while not perfect at least I can have MPC-HC for...
    Tried with a custom LAV build from @Sebastiii (0.68.5 git) and got a bit further :) - Works with MPC-HC (no image corruption) as...
    Hi, Been trying out some 2160P releases recently and came across an odd issue with HEVC playback, it will run at a reduced...
    Replies
    16
    Views
    3K
    Top Bottom