Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="dedi" data-source="post: 607358" data-attributes="member: 101658">Re: SAF v4.10 experimental (based on FFDShow DXVA decoder)I made some codec testings.Nvidia GT 240, AMD Athon II X4, Supertalent SSD GX 64, Win 7 x64, MP RC2, SAF 5.0 12.4. unlocked, ffdshow audio codec&nbsp;Here are my notes (sorry only notes):Sfi(news) PDVD10 &nbsp; &nbsp; dxva autoselect smooth, not perfect lines but no pulses&nbsp; &nbsp; dxva bob smooth, not perfect lines but no pulses&nbsp; &nbsp; dxva weave stutter sometimes, pulsesSFi(news) PDVD9 &nbsp; &nbsp; dxva force bob [best lines in EVR]&nbsp; &nbsp; dxva force weave not perfect smooth, not nice lines&nbsp; &nbsp; dxva autoselect not perfect smooth, not nice linesSFi(news) ffdshow some framedrops at begin, disapeared. moving bar looks very good. line not very even, sometimes short. pulses/framedrop very rare.HDsuisse(movie) PDVD9 &nbsp; &nbsp; force bob + dxva -&gt; visually perfect (even it reports as many framedrops as drawn), line has some very short pulses &nbsp; &nbsp; force weave + sw -&gt; slow + fd&nbsp; &nbsp; force weave + dxva -&gt; 1fd/sec with visual stuttering&nbsp; &nbsp; autoselect + dxva -&gt; visually perfect (even it reports as many framedrops as drawn), line has some very short pulses &nbsp; &nbsp; HDsuisse ffdshow dxva video stuttering very hard or even freeze &nbsp; &nbsp; after disabling post processing, even cpu was low when enabled. ( what causes this?) -&gt; almost perfect, not always perfect line, but often.&nbsp; some less fd (7 out of 2000 not always) with pulses&nbsp;Conclusion:Best Playback with: SD: fddshow (resize works also without problems) or PDVD9HD: ffdshow DXVA with post processing disabled or PDVD9but it seems every codec works quite &quot;fine&quot;. i had some troubles first with ffdshow, dont know the reason, it just gone. i also made the discovery that background programs (in my case WindowsLive Messenger and Desktop Window Manager (dwm.exe) ) caused light stutters about every 4 sec. Wonder why on a quad with a SSD, there should be no reason for.I have the impression that PDVD SD uses weave and HD bob. Is this correct? or a setting thing (auto uses last setting used first?) ffdshow seems to use bob with SD.I also discovered crashes when switching from HD to SD channels, i dont know if this bug is SAF or MP related.crash from zapping HD -&gt; SDPDVD9 -&gt; PVDV10ffdshow -&gt; ffdshownot: PVDV9 -&gt; ffdshowUpdate: i still get framedrops which i cant reproduce constantly. Seems some Channels hit this problem more. also i got some audio sync problems, this may caused from the ffdshow upscaling process. im investigating this 2 problemsUpdate 06.05: I now use PDVD10 for SD and HD. Runs smooth</blockquote>

[QUOTE="dedi, post: 607358, member: 101658"] [b]Re: SAF v4.10 experimental (based on FFDShow DXVA decoder)[/b] I made some codec testings. Nvidia GT 240, AMD Athon II X4, Supertalent SSD GX 64, Win 7 x64, MP RC2, SAF 5.0 12.4. unlocked, ffdshow audio codec [B]Here are my notes[/B] (sorry only notes): Sfi(news) [B]PDVD10 [/B] dxva autoselect smooth, not perfect lines but no pulses dxva bob smooth, not perfect lines but no pulses dxva weave stutter sometimes, pulses SFi(news) [B]PDVD9 [/B] dxva force bob [best lines in EVR] dxva force weave not perfect smooth, not nice lines dxva autoselect not perfect smooth, not nice lines SFi(news) [B]ffdshow [/B]some framedrops at begin, disapeared. moving bar looks very good. line not very even, sometimes short. pulses/framedrop very rare. HDsuisse(movie) [B]PDVD9 [/B] force bob + dxva -> visually perfect (even it reports as many framedrops as drawn), line has some very short pulses force weave + sw -> slow + fd force weave + dxva -> 1fd/sec with visual stuttering autoselect + dxva -> visually perfect (even it reports as many framedrops as drawn), line has some very short pulses HDsuisse [B]ffdshow [/B]dxva video stuttering very hard or even freeze after disabling post processing, even cpu was low when enabled. ( what causes this?) -> almost perfect, not always perfect line, but often. some less fd (7 out of 2000 not always) with pulses [B][U]Conclusion:[/U][/B] Best Playback with: SD: fddshow (resize works also without problems) or PDVD9 HD: ffdshow DXVA with post processing disabled or PDVD9 but it seems every codec works quite "fine". i had some troubles first with ffdshow, dont know the reason, it just gone. i also made the discovery that background programs (in my case WindowsLive Messenger and Desktop Window Manager (dwm.exe) ) caused light stutters about every 4 sec. Wonder why on a quad with a SSD, there should be no reason for. I have the impression that PDVD SD uses weave and HD bob. Is this correct? or a setting thing (auto uses last setting used first?) ffdshow seems to use bob with SD. I also discovered crashes when switching from HD to SD channels, i dont know if this bug is SAF or MP related. [B]crash from zapping HD -> SD[/B] PDVD9 -> PVDV10 ffdshow -> ffdshow not: PVDV9 -> ffdshow Update: i still get framedrops which i cant reproduce constantly. Seems some Channels hit this problem more. also i got some audio sync problems, this may caused from the ffdshow upscaling process. im investigating this 2 problems Update 06.05: I now use PDVD10 for SD and HD. Runs smooth [/QUOTE]

Verification