Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="risu" data-source="post: 518532" data-attributes="member: 25038">Actually all my IQ problems were with mkvtoolnix, can't say for sure about lipsync etc. If you browse through mkvtoolnix dev thread over doom you can spot quite amount of users having random failures. And yes, most of them has been corrected while issues arise, but I didn't like watching every converted file afterwards just to make sure it worked. And I did experience situations where data was corrupted. I'm sure mkv will be better when time passes by as all different stream types get better support (things can't evolve that much in blu-ray as it is standardized).Regarding MKV audiotracks. There really is NO reason to convert regular DTS or AC3 into lossless FLAC. You don't gain ANY audio quality and your files will be larger. Only reason to use FLAC is to convert DTS Master Audio, EAC3 and TrueHD tracks with full resolution. And EAC3 is questionable too if your system has correct audio codec available for it. EAC3 dev thread has list of all needed codecs for each audio stream type to have perfect sound conversion for FLAC.</blockquote>

[QUOTE="risu, post: 518532, member: 25038"] Actually all my IQ problems were with mkvtoolnix, can't say for sure about lipsync etc. If you browse through mkvtoolnix dev thread over doom you can spot quite amount of users having random failures. And yes, most of them has been corrected while issues arise, but I didn't like watching every converted file afterwards just to make sure it worked. And I did experience situations where data was corrupted. I'm sure mkv will be better when time passes by as all different stream types get better support (things can't evolve that much in blu-ray as it is standardized). Regarding MKV audiotracks. There really is NO reason to convert regular DTS or AC3 into lossless FLAC. You don't gain ANY audio quality and your files will be larger. Only reason to use FLAC is to convert DTS Master Audio, EAC3 and TrueHD tracks with full resolution. And EAC3 is questionable too if your system has correct audio codec available for it. EAC3 dev thread has list of all needed codecs for each audio stream type to have perfect sound conversion for FLAC. [/QUOTE]

Verification