Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="ScRePt" data-source="post: 920112" data-attributes="member: 106152">Thanks for your feedback man. Here are my comments:&nbsp;1. Codeplex is the issue tracker for this project. Please report bugs/features there2. Your &quot;filter list&quot; starts with &quot;3dtv.at Stereo Renderer&quot;. That is a Renderer that is not supported by MP. It is not a filter. The plugin can not help.3. Just adding 1 more filter is enough. It works for me at least. The plugin also &quot;illegally&quot; enables/disables the function, ie MP does not allow this. The other filters in the chain are automatically loaded by MP. No need for the plugin to change sth.4. I am not aware of the &quot;Automatic Decoder Settings&quot; thingy. Does it break MP3D? (not in the case of DXVA). I do not follow why you mentioned it.5. The SVI file could be supported in the future. It is not dismissed. Needs some research: There are numerus other ways of storing 3D information ... What would happen to users without SVI files? To users without &quot;write-access&quot; to the video folder? Should MP3D settings override the SVI? What about metadata in mkv containers? Shouldn't the plugin also &quot;guess&quot; the source format from the filename? Dude, it's not that simple ... trust me, I want that feature too!5. What do you &quot;Sacrifice&quot; appart from DXVA? Please let me know. Would it be acceptable if the DXVA turned-off during 3d? I BET that's &quot;illegal&quot; in MP too but I can try!6. The whole plugin SHOULD NOT be a plugin. It does too many &quot;illegal&quot; things ... It started as a PoC and MP could embrace it as build-in feature ....&nbsp;.. and about the &quot;shame&quot; + &quot;skilled coders&quot; + &quot;take over&quot;: I think I was nice to you. Please ...</blockquote>

[QUOTE="ScRePt, post: 920112, member: 106152"] Thanks for your feedback man. Here are my comments: 1. Codeplex is the issue tracker for this project. Please report bugs/features there 2. Your "filter list" starts with "3dtv.at Stereo Renderer". That is a Renderer that is not supported by MP. It is not a filter. The plugin can not help. 3. Just adding 1 more filter is enough. It works for me at least. The plugin also "illegally" enables/disables the function, ie MP does not allow this. The other filters in the chain are automatically loaded by MP. No need for the plugin to change sth. 4. I am not aware of the "Automatic Decoder Settings" thingy. Does it break MP3D? (not in the case of DXVA). I do not follow why you mentioned it. 5. The SVI file could be supported in the future. It is not dismissed. Needs some research: There are numerus other ways of storing 3D information ... What would happen to users without SVI files? To users without "write-access" to the video folder? Should MP3D settings override the SVI? What about metadata in mkv containers? Shouldn't the plugin also "guess" the source format from the filename? Dude, it's not that simple ... trust me, I want that feature too! 5. What do you "Sacrifice" appart from DXVA? Please let me know. Would it be acceptable if the DXVA turned-off during 3d? I BET that's "illegal" in MP too but I can try! 6. The whole plugin SHOULD NOT be a plugin. It does too many "illegal" things ... It started as a PoC and MP could embrace it as build-in feature .... .. and about the "shame" + "skilled coders" + "take over": I think I was nice to you. Please ... [/QUOTE]

Verification