[Music] Adding Composer to the Music DB (1 Viewer)

GoldenEye

MP Donator
  • Premium Supporter
  • October 26, 2005
    300
    26
    Switzerland
    Switzerland Switzerland
    Country flag
    Started on: 2007-02-18
    Last update: 2007-02-18

    Summary:

    I am a happy user of MP and use the music module regularly for listening to my classical music collection. There is an issue with this: When listening to classical music, one concentrates on the composer rather than the artist. Unfortunately, the composer tag is not read by MP's tag reader. If MP was able to store the composer to the DB, this would add an awesome value to the product.

    Description:

    Enhance the tag reader so that it reads the composer tag and adds it to the music database.

    Thanks for considering this enhancement feature

    G.
     

    Joche

    Portal Member
    February 18, 2007
    46
    0
    Stockholm
    Sweden Sweden
    I second this request so now we are two who wants it, almost a revolution or atleast a folk storm.

    Started on: 2007-02-18
    Last update: 2007-02-18

    Summary:

    I am a happy user of MP and use the music module regularly for listening to my classical music collection. There is an issue with this: When listening to classical music, one concentrates on the composer rather than the artist. Unfortunately, the composer tag is not read by MP's tag reader. If MP was able to store the composer to the DB, this would add an awesome value to the product.

    Description:

    Enhance the tag reader so that it reads the composer tag and adds it to the music database.

    Thanks for considering this enhancement feature

    G.
     

    bassio

    Portal Member
    June 7, 2007
    10
    0
    69
    Yeah me too

    Count me in too!!

    And it will be great to have the ability to add composer pics to the database along so we can browse by composer (with the pics) :p
     

    MacMini

    Portal Pro
    May 16, 2006
    206
    0
    Composer, or what MS calls "Artist."

    It is rare, but MS does have some good ideas. By having "Artist" and "Album Artist" you can assign, for instance:

    Artist: Bach
    Abum Artist: Glenn Gould

    or

    Artist: Bach
    Album Artist: Suske

    (and of course:
    Artist: Bush
    Album Artist: Bush)

    Then you can sort by artist to see each composer's works together, or by album artist to see it all grouped by the performer.

    Same result, but a bit more versatile and more practical, than just a "Composer" field. Obviously, the composer in pop music is not all that significant to most users, and adding the several composers who are listed on that Bush album, and the hundreds of other composers from all your other pop albums, would make searching for Bach a much more difficult task.

    This is why I think Artist/Album artist is a better idea.
     

    rsbrux

    Documentation Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • April 15, 2007
    1,029
    93
    Switzerland Switzerland
    Country flag
    Sorry, MacMini, but your interpretation of these tags doesn't agree with conventional usage. The "Artist" tag is used to store the performer, not the composer. That this was the MS intention can be inferred from the way they rendered it in German: "Interpret". This information can also be important to the classical music fan, and is not necessarily the same as "Album Artist". Consider a compilation CD containing a Mozart aria sung by Anna Nettrebko.
    The MP3 tags include a separate "Composer" tag. Unfortunately, few of the HTPC or MP3-player solutions pay any attention to it. The only one I know of that does is JRiver's Media Center. I chose MP over JRiver mainly because JRiver had a very limited 10' interface ("Theater View") when I performed my evaluation.
     

    GoldenEye

    MP Donator
  • Premium Supporter
  • October 26, 2005
    300
    26
    Switzerland
    Switzerland Switzerland
    Country flag
    I agree with you, rsbrux.

    However, I have given up hope that the sortware industry willl solve our issue in their mediaplayer applications (we're not talking solely about a MediaPortal issue). And if they solved the problem, there are many following issues, e.g. how would we create consistent views in MediaPortal without creating specific classical views (I don't own only classical music but also Jazz, Pop, Rock etc.)?

    Therefore, I have recently decided to re-tag my classical music collection. I have found the following guidelines which I will follow: http://musicbrainz.org/doc/ClassicalStyleGuide. This seems to be a resonable way to do it.

    G.
     

    rsbrux

    Documentation Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • April 15, 2007
    1,029
    93
    Switzerland Switzerland
    Country flag
    Hi G,
    Thanks for the link. While I can't subscribe to all of it, there are some good ideas in it. At least, it would solve my current problem of being confronted with long lists of "Adagio", "Allegro" and "Andante" in the title view.
    R.
     

    MacMini

    Portal Pro
    May 16, 2006
    206
    0
    Sorry, MacMini, but your interpretation of these tags doesn't agree with conventional usage. The "Artist" tag is used to store the performer, not the composer....
    Fine, so reverse the order. But the larger point is still valid.

    Face it: you are not going to get a main menu composer tag, simply because popular music cares less about composers, that performers. Few people care deeply who was the composer of Genie In A Bottle by Christina Aguilera.

    At the same time, composers are obviously important in classical music. But since often various composers of pop music are listed in the tags, if you have a mixed collection (and most do,) then sorting by "Composer" is going to be a total mess, because all too often in pop every other song is by a different composer.

    So, having categories for both "Artist" and "Album Artist" is good, because if you use your imagination, you can assign one of these two to the Composer and the other to the Performer. Then you can sort either by albums of music composed by Mozart, or by albums of music sung by Netrebko. And for most of your pop music, the two categories would be the same.

    It may not fit perfectly in established convention, but it works.
     

    rsbrux

    Documentation Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • April 15, 2007
    1,029
    93
    Switzerland Switzerland
    Country flag
    MacMini,
    For lack of anything better, I have indeed adopted a "hybrid" solution, along the lines you suggest. Generally, if a classical album is dedicated to one composer, I put the composer's name in both the "Artist" and "Album Artist" tags. Only if the album contains material by different composers but is all by the same performer do I put the performer's name in the artist tags. For "composer" albums, I keep the soloist, choir and orchestra information in the comment tag at present. If I had a displayable composer tag, I wouldn't bother filling it for pop music, so it would be easy to filter it out to list music by composer.
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

    OP Similar threads Forum Replies Date
    DHosein Adding Custom Artwork? My TVSeries 3
    raffe [TV] Option for adding IPTV channels without checking Improvement Suggestions 2
    Rob Hexenmeister Navigation problems adding menu buttons to EPG General Support 1
    BrownGhost MP-TVSeries, Failed to save xml to cache, and not adding any info to tvseries from tvdb My TVSeries 4
    G How best to get cover art for tracks to show up on the Audio Menu (Latest Added, Unplayed)? General 9
    Neoculture "Recently Added" option My TVSeries 8
    doskabouter No guide info added due to a MYSQL deadlock Electronic Program Guide 1
    morpheus_xx [WiP] Adding 64 bit support to MP2 MediaPortal 2 31
    Hawkeye Changes to last added view Feature Requests 0
    P Media portal not adding all TV series General 2
    B some music videos stutter Watch / Listen Media 0
    horned_reaper [solved] When playing music Fanart does not shuffle Fanart Handler 20
    horned_reaper [solved] When playing music Fanart does not appear immediately after downloading Fanart Handler 272
    horned_reaper [Music] 5012: Start current music track from the beginning Improvement Suggestions 37
    horned_reaper [solved] 5012: Restart current music track General Support 13
    atlantic How to use Spotify inside Mediaportal? Listen Music 18
    horned_reaper [solved] Music playback hangs General Support 58
    globaldonkey Music Database Error Listen Music 1
    joecrow Music on Headphones Listen Music 8
    2BitSculptor MP 1.23.. music stops playing General Support 6
    Sarxas What Music Are You Listening To? OffTopic 0
    Edwardfc [solved] Mp 2.2.1 Configuration Issues - Goes to Sleep while playing Music General 6
    G [fixed] [MP2-786] Party Music Player can only play playlists with less than 1000 items 2.2 Archive 7
    KlausWirn Music crash Bass crash no change to play music Installation, configuration support 2
    BlueMax1916 [confirm] Music: Every 2nd track skipped MediaPortal 2 30
    Similar threads

























    Top Bottom