Reply to thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="elliottmc" data-source="post: 331309" data-attributes="member: 14268">Notwithstanding the smiley, I'm not sure I'd agree with your assessment that this is a feature request. If you can record radio, but not play it back, then this is not what any reasonable user would expect. Therefore, most people would consider this to be a bug.The tsreader design might be the cause of the problem, but why not get it into Mantis with no specified timeframe/version just so that it is &quot;in the system&quot;? This would also apply to many other bugs which I see reported every couple of months but which don't get officially logged or commented on.Not moaning, partly because I don't use the radio very often. Just offering a user's perspective. Despite a few quirks, MP beats the competition hands down, and I am sure that the team are stressed out trying to get RC4 out, and then fix the remaining bugs for 1.0. Personally, I'd like to see 1.0 out the door, and then a serious bug hunt to locate all remaining issues and consider ways of fixing them. I only wish I could do some of the fixing myself rather than just reporting. I'm more than happy to help verify bugs and try to keep track of them, if this would help.Mark</blockquote>

[QUOTE="elliottmc, post: 331309, member: 14268"] Notwithstanding the smiley, I'm not sure I'd agree with your assessment that this is a feature request. If you can record radio, but not play it back, then this is not what any reasonable user would expect. Therefore, most people would consider this to be a bug. The tsreader design might be the cause of the problem, but why not get it into Mantis with no specified timeframe/version just so that it is "in the system"? This would also apply to many other bugs which I see reported every couple of months but which don't get officially logged or commented on. Not moaning, partly because I don't use the radio very often. Just offering a user's perspective. Despite a few quirks, MP beats the competition hands down, and I am sure that the team are stressed out trying to get RC4 out, and then fix the remaining bugs for 1.0. Personally, I'd like to see 1.0 out the door, and then a serious bug hunt to locate all remaining issues and consider ways of fixing them. I only wish I could do some of the fixing myself rather than just reporting. I'm more than happy to help verify bugs and try to keep track of them, if this would help. Mark [/QUOTE]

Verification