There are 3 scenarios - and last does not work well:
1. There is planned TV recording and PC is in S3 mode: PC wake ups, make a recording and go to S3 back - this is fine
2. There is life TV with no recording & no timishifting) and than command to go to S3 by remote control: HTPC goes to S3
- this is fine
3. There si life TV with recording & timishifting and than command to go to S3 by remote control: HTPC goes to away mode, after the recording is finish it should go to S3 but it remains in away mode - this is I think not correct.
To be more specific to point 3 the HTPC does not go to S3 mode only when timeshifting is ON. When the timeshift is OFF (TV is switch OFF), then the HTPC goes to S3 mode from away mode after the recording has finished.
This kind of behaviour for situation 3 is also common for DVR machines - user does not care about status of the DVR, when the user wants to switch off DVR, customer just press the sleep button and does not care any more - when no TV recording than DVR goes to S3 immediatelly, when DVR is recording something, it goes to away mode and after the recording it goes to the S3 mode automatically.
In case of Windows Media Center it also does not go to S3 mode from away mode when the recording has finished, but there is workaround available - MCE Standby Tool SW (http://slicksolutions.eu/mst.shtml), which manage to go MCE to S3 from away mode when the TV recording is finished (while the htpc is in away mode already during the recording).
M.
1. There is planned TV recording and PC is in S3 mode: PC wake ups, make a recording and go to S3 back - this is fine
2. There is life TV with no recording & no timishifting) and than command to go to S3 by remote control: HTPC goes to S3
- this is fine
3. There si life TV with recording & timishifting and than command to go to S3 by remote control: HTPC goes to away mode, after the recording is finish it should go to S3 but it remains in away mode - this is I think not correct.
To be more specific to point 3 the HTPC does not go to S3 mode only when timeshifting is ON. When the timeshift is OFF (TV is switch OFF), then the HTPC goes to S3 mode from away mode after the recording has finished.
This kind of behaviour for situation 3 is also common for DVR machines - user does not care about status of the DVR, when the user wants to switch off DVR, customer just press the sleep button and does not care any more - when no TV recording than DVR goes to S3 immediatelly, when DVR is recording something, it goes to away mode and after the recording it goes to the S3 mode automatically.
In case of Windows Media Center it also does not go to S3 mode from away mode when the recording has finished, but there is workaround available - MCE Standby Tool SW (http://slicksolutions.eu/mst.shtml), which manage to go MCE to S3 from away mode when the TV recording is finished (while the htpc is in away mode already during the recording).
M.