- August 20, 2007
- 2,159
- 750
- Moderator
- #81
AW: Re: My Films 5 - AMC Updater
As I already mentioned, if it is possible, to have an ID like IMDB, you can already (in Grabber script editor) define different main and/or subpages to get data from different sites - and finally use that mapping to merge that data into one final result. I do this for example in IMDB-OFDB scraper using OFDB-description as primary, overwriting with IMDB-description if none exists in ODFB. Same can be done with e.g. Cover.
But to get this properly working, you need a "link" between those sites - like it is possible between IMDB, OFDB and TMDB. Cinefacts unfortunately seems NOT to have such an ID (a pity, as I use that one too often ....).
Regarding getting the "richest" data - I understand what you mean - and this is easy from "computing" point of view - but the longest text is not always the best and I would assume many users would not be too happy about such an approach. If "a lot of info" is your goal, I would recommend two other options/alternatives:
- Use the web links (via BrowseTheWeb plugin) to read more about the selected movie
- Modify the grabber script to e.g. get all comments for a movie - or even more extended data by merging it into a field - this could be done by grabbing data from a subpage.
- title handling
- media info
- internet info
- cover artwork
- person thumbs
- fanart
As currently, we have (for single movie updates):
- update all data (overwriting all existing)
- add only missing data
- update one selected field (could be data, image)
So basically you would like to see another option there to update "all non artwork data" ?
See my answer to z3us - I think that approach is something we can think about.@halfblade - I just wanted to add to Guzzi's rather extensive answer that I also agree with your point(s). Guzzi and I have discussed it A LOT - particulary about improving the AMCUpdater interface. Remember AMCUpdater has been around for a while. Guzzi just integrated it in My Films 5 to make importing new films a lot easier. I never used it before because I found it too complex. BUT now, in My Films 5, I usually import new films via the GUI - Global Update DB (as Guzzi said), because it is so easy and so far all my new films have matched perfectly (I am sure some won't and I will probably add those via AMCU where you get total control over matching.)
However, before we change the interface for AMCU we really wanted to get more user feedback. So your post was really helpful. If you can provide more specific suggestions of how you think it could work better, or even mock up screens of your ideas, that would be great![]()
Thanks for all your answers. I had only little time since my post but I'll look onto MyFilms again in depth this weekend. Than I'll try to become more exactly. I love MyFilms and I wish I would have more freetime to support you.
I have to look more exactly on AMCU and I'll report asap.
That would be great.Two features I would like to have are:
- possibility of choosing which AMCu cfg to use when performing a global update from inside the GUI
- updating info from internet with batch mode![]()
My workflow is similar - just that I use IMDB-OFDB as primary scraper - and just fix problems in MyFilms GUI afterwards, like updating data, artwork, etc.Here some more words on my process. Perhaps it helps to understand what I would love in my particular case. Even that I know that other people work in another way with it.
When I import a movie I normally try to get so many data as possible.
1) Import data with my main scraper (in my case cinefacts german)
2) Sometimes it happens that there is not enough data than I scrap data from other scrapers, too (for example ofdb/imdb ...)
3) When covers / fanarts haven't been found OR when covers / fanart are in poor quality (which happens more often than I want) I scrap these from MovieGoods (for example)
That is imho practically not possible - as users would have to make separate selections for each scraper, that cannot do an automatch.It would be great something like this::
Download data from all selected scrapers and than automatically choose the "richest" data per field. For example let's say the first scraper has only 5 words in the description and the second one has 100. Than take the description of the 100 word scraper![]()
As I already mentioned, if it is possible, to have an ID like IMDB, you can already (in Grabber script editor) define different main and/or subpages to get data from different sites - and finally use that mapping to merge that data into one final result. I do this for example in IMDB-OFDB scraper using OFDB-description as primary, overwriting with IMDB-description if none exists in ODFB. Same can be done with e.g. Cover.
But to get this properly working, you need a "link" between those sites - like it is possible between IMDB, OFDB and TMDB. Cinefacts unfortunately seems NOT to have such an ID (a pity, as I use that one too often ....).
Regarding getting the "richest" data - I understand what you mean - and this is easy from "computing" point of view - but the longest text is not always the best and I would assume many users would not be too happy about such an approach. If "a lot of info" is your goal, I would recommend two other options/alternatives:
- Use the web links (via BrowseTheWeb plugin) to read more about the selected movie
- Modify the grabber script to e.g. get all comments for a movie - or even more extended data by merging it into a field - this could be done by grabbing data from a subpage.
internally, there is even more "areas":Furthermore there should always be 3 scraper steps. One step for data, one for coverart and one for fanart.
- title handling
- media info
- internet info
- cover artwork
- person thumbs
- fanart
Not sure, what ou mean by "3 step scraping" - do you wish clustered update options in MyFilms GUI?So for example. Moviegoods has normally much better high quality fanart than cinefacts or imdb so it would be great to achieve this 3 step scraping.
As currently, we have (for single movie updates):
- update all data (overwriting all existing)
- add only missing data
- update one selected field (could be data, image)
So basically you would like to see another option there to update "all non artwork data" ?
Germany