SofaBaton X1S review - A nice replacement for my Harmony One (1 Viewer)

Wyatt

Portal Member
December 22, 2014
7
3
Home Country
Australia Australia
I don't have a complicated A/V system - a Sony A8H TV, Yamaha receiver, and a HTPC on which I run most media through MediaPortal. I have used various universal remotes (Philips Pronto and Harmony) to control different iterations of this system for many years. I bought the SofaBaton to replace a Harmony One that was becoming less responsive, not holding charge very well, and had a cracked screen that was starting to obscure things. In summary, the SofaBaton has been able to do all of the things the Harmony One was able to do - probably even more. Here's a list of some of the pros and cons I've found after nearly 3 weeks of use.


Pros:

- The remote works well to turn everything on and off. I usually leave the input on the same setting so I haven't really tested input switching, but I imagine that would work well.

- I've paired the SofaBaton with a Flirc to control MediaPortal and for the most part that's working OK. I've even managed to get functions like Subtitle and Context Menu to work, which I was never able to do with any of my Harmonys.

- I like that the screen is not a touch screen. I don't know how many times I accidentally touched the Harmony screen and randomly changed what I was watching or doing.

- Battery life is phenomenal - I've been using it for nearly 3 weeks and it's still over 50% charged. I was charging my Harmony every 2-3 days.


Cons

- The set up was a bit funky. If I didn't have so much experience setting up Harmony and Prontos, I might have struggled a bit. Reading some of the forums in advance also helped identify some issues early.

- IR signals: I originally put the hub into my TV cabinet where my Harmony hub used to be, but it wouldn't turn my TV on. I connected an IR blaster and put it near the area where the TV receives its IR signal, but it still didn't work. In the end, I had to put the hub on top of the TV cabinet, which didn't please my wife, but now we're used to it and don't notice it.

- No clicks and double clicks: There are plenty of times when I have to press a button twice to get a function to work. Maybe it’s because I hadn't moved the remote enough to bring it back to life to ensure that the first click was recognised. Maybe it's because I haven't pressed the button hard enough. This is a minor irritation. More annoying is the double and sometimes triple clicks that I get from a single press. It's a bit annoying when you're trying to skip 30 sec forward and end up skipping 10 minutes! It's erratic as well - there's no consistent pattern so it's going to be hard to troubleshoot.

- The case: It's not shiny, but it's quite smooth, so it's quite slippery. I've already had it slip off the couch a number of time onto the floor.

- The screen and buttons: In my opinion the remote could benefit from one more row of buttons. I think the screen size could be reduced a bit to allow for another row of buttons. I know, each button can be used twice with a short press and a long press, but then I have to remember what's what and also teach my wife what's what. Not easy.

Overall, it seems like there are more cons than pros, but on balance, the pros far outweigh the cons and I'm enjoying using the SofaBaton X1S remote. It is a worthy replacement for my Harmony One, maybe even better!
 

doskabouter

Development Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • September 27, 2009
    4,640
    3,071
    Nuenen
    Home Country
    Netherlands Netherlands
    thanks for the review.
    I'm still using my harmony one for god knows how many years.
    Overhere it gets charged every night, and I need to replace my battery around every 7 years.
    After all those years it's still functional except the "7" button, you really have to press it very firmly to do something.

    I do heavily use some custom buttons I've programmed on the harmony, (subtitles +/- delay, appclose, start MP) and I haven't found a good alternative for that.
    I guess that having a couple of extra buttons isn't really possible on that SofaBaton?
     

    harryzwo

    Portal Pro
    July 25, 2006
    876
    115
    Home Country
    Germany Germany
    I also bought a Sofabaton x1s and am having several problems setting it up. What code did you load for the media portal? I have it with 'Microsoft Media Center' and 'Microsoft Remote Control 1040'. The problem I have with both is that the 'left' navigation key doesn't work. the others do. I can only navigate left once, so repeating is not possible. Then the Play/Pause button doesn't work. It's just a break. I also learned the relevant commands, but that didn't help either.

    Can you confirm these issues and how did you fix them?
     

    Wyatt

    Portal Member
    December 22, 2014
    7
    3
    Home Country
    Australia Australia
    Hi there, I chose "Microsoft" from the menu (I can't see from the app anything more specific than that) and then used a Flirc to pair the controls with keyboard keys.
     

    harryzwo

    Portal Pro
    July 25, 2006
    876
    115
    Home Country
    Germany Germany
    there are many codes under 'Microsoft'. I tried 'Microsoft Media Center'. The “navigation links” don’t work here. I can only click left once, after which it only works again when I use another key. 'Pause/Play' doesn't work either, only pause works here. Neither correction using the cloud nor direct training works for me
     

    Wyatt

    Portal Member
    December 22, 2014
    7
    3
    Home Country
    Australia Australia
    Sorry, I'm not sure if I can help any further. I'm effectively operating MediaPortal through Flirc, not directly via the SofaBaton.
     

    harryzwo

    Portal Pro
    July 25, 2006
    876
    115
    Home Country
    Germany Germany
    why do you need the sofa baton? The goal is to control everything with just one remote control.
     

    Wyatt

    Portal Member
    December 22, 2014
    7
    3
    Home Country
    Australia Australia
    I am only using the one remote control. With the SofaBaton I can do all the usual functions that a universal remote does - like turn on and off all of my components, manage the inputs etc. But because MediaPortal is a progam running on a HTPC, it doesn't operate the same way as a standard component. There are probably lots of ways of controlling it, but I've chosen to do it by pairing the remote to a Flirc. If you don't know what a Flirc is, I suggest googling it.
     

    harryzwo

    Portal Pro
    July 25, 2006
    876
    115
    Home Country
    Germany Germany
    Many thanks for the answer.

    So far I've used Logitech's Harmony hub. This allows you to control all components (including the media portal). I have now contacted the Sofabaton hotline. It should also work here like with the Harmony. Unfortunately, not all of the IR codes are correct. You can also learn commands here. But that doesn't work properly either. Apparently there is still a lot to be improved in the Sofabaton software. Whether this is still relevant to me remains to be seen.
     

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Top Bottom