[solved] No sound in Videos (DTS), but in TV (1 Viewer)

Hotkey

MP Donator
  • Premium Supporter
  • July 18, 2007
    254
    6
    43
    Dortmund
    Home Country
    Germany Germany
    Hi there,

    after i replaced my old Panasonic SA-XR55 with a new Onkyo for my HTPC, i decided to use the Panasonic for my Gaming PC which also runs Mediaportal Client and is connected to the MP-Server.

    The PC is connected via optical cable to the Panasonic (Soundcard Soundblaster-Z). As i wanted to use Dolby Digital Live for games i activated this option in the Soundblaster Settings (see Screenshots below).
    I also installed the SAF Package v.6.3.1.

    Now my Problem is, that i get Good Sound for Music, good Sound for TV (also AC3 working) but No-Sound for DTS-Movies. When i start a movie with Non DTS and DTS Sound-Stream i do get sound with the non-DTS but when i switch to DTS the Playback just stops and i'm back in the Movies Menu (Moving Pictures actually).

    When i start the same movies with the MPC (Media Player Classig) i also get perfect sound.

    So short and punchy: Sound Problem only with DTS-Audio when played with Mediaportal.

    Please finde the Screenshots below with my settings, the overlay of both TV (girls) and Video (good old robert redfort) and also attached the log.

    I appreciate any help, many thanks in advance!

    LAV-Audio-Settings.jpg soundblaster-settings.jpg sound-settings.jpg TV.jpg tv-codecs.jpg video.jpg video-codecs.jpg
     

    mm1352000

    Development Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • September 1, 2008
    21,577
    8,223
    Home Country
    New Zealand New Zealand
    I'm confused.
    You said that the receiver is connected using optical S/PDIF.
    Your MediaPortal config is showing that you use the default DirectSound audio renderer.
    According to the screenshot of the Windows audio devices, the Windows default audio output is analog speakers ("Lautsprecher") instead of "SPDIF-Out". So, MediaPortal will be sending sound to the analog output instead of the S/PDIF output.
    I don't understand how that can work. Shouldn't the Windows default audio output be "SPDIF-Out"? :confused:

    Also, what happens if you untick the LAV audio codec DTS bitstreaming option (which is currently ticked)?
     

    spachti

    Portal Pro
    July 27, 2005
    374
    100
    Bible Belt
    Home Country
    United States of America United States of America
    It's a special setting in the soundblaster program. It's a actually described there in one of the pictures. It's in German, that's probably the reason you haven't read it.

    Quote/
    To use the dolby digital live via spdif you have to use the speaker output setting in the windows sound configuration..
     

    mm1352000

    Development Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • September 1, 2008
    21,577
    8,223
    Home Country
    New Zealand New Zealand
    Ahh, English translation:
    http://attachments.team-mediaportal.com/2014/12/212750_upload_2014-12-1_12-10-4.png

    So if this was going to work for DTS, surely the DD Live encoder (or whatever is doing this "fancy" conversion) would either have to:
    1. Recognise that the DTS audio is already encoded compatible with the S/PDIF output and should just be passed through to that S/PDIF output without doing any re-encoding, OR...
    2. Decode the DTS audio to PCM, and then re-encode PCM as DD/AC-3 (which is the normal DD Live function).
    This is why I asked about what happens if the LAV bitstreaming option is disabled. That way the DTS would be decoded by LAV, and when it reaches the DD Live encoder it will be PCM. My hypothesis is that the DD Live encoder should be able to encode the PCM and so the audio should work.

    Again and in other words, the point I'm trying to make is that I wonder if the DTS can really be bitstreamed (without re-encoding) through the DD Live function. I suspect it will either have to be decoded to PCM then encoded as DD/AC-3 by DD Live... or otherwise you will have to disable DD Live for use with MediaPortal.
     

    mm1352000

    Development Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • September 1, 2008
    21,577
    8,223
    Home Country
    New Zealand New Zealand
    Since the short description also says the program will use the windows sound exclusively and no other media player will work, i'm not sure if this isn't his real problem.
    Oh for sure - the audio must either go through DD Live somehow, or DD Live must be disabled.
     

    Hotkey

    MP Donator
  • Premium Supporter
  • July 18, 2007
    254
    6
    43
    Dortmund
    Home Country
    Germany Germany
    Hi all,

    first of all many thanks for all the hints and the discussion.

    I must say that i'm a little confused about what setting i should change now ;-)

    This is why I asked about what happens if the LAV bitstreaming option is disabled
    ..
    So should i disable the "DTS" Tickmark in the LAV Audio settings?

    What is the reason that the same Movie works fine with Media Player Classic and that the problem does not exists for TV?

    Again, thanks a lot!
     

    mm1352000

    Development Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • September 1, 2008
    21,577
    8,223
    Home Country
    New Zealand New Zealand
    So should i disable the "DTS" Tickmark in the LAV Audio settings?
    Yes, please try that.

    What is the reason that the same Movie works fine with Media Player Classic and that the problem does not exists for TV?
    For MPC: I assume MPC is not configured to bitstream [for DTS]. It will decode the audio to PCM, the DD Live encoder will be able to encode it, and so you will have audio.

    For TV with MPEG 1, MPEG 2, and/or HE-AAC audio: those audio streams cannot be bitstreamed and will always be decoded to PCM. Therefore the DD Live encoder should have no problem encoding those streams, and you will have audio.

    For TV with DD/AC-3 audio: you have disabled bitstreaming in the LAV audio codec so the DD/AC-3 will be decoded to PCM. Therefore the DD Live encoder should have no problem encoding those streams, and you will have audio.

    In short: we expect you will have a problem in any application where you enable bitstreaming.
     

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Similar threads

    MP1 MP2 1.25.0 No Sound DE
    If your remote control is the Ortek VRC-1100 or the Hama equivalent, you must be using the "Centarea HID" in MP, and possibly using the AutoHotKey script that I wrote for it. This script checks for the "green marble" button, and starts MP from the desktop when that button is pressed. Changing this script to invoke (say)...
    If your remote control is the Ortek VRC-1100 or the Hama equivalent, you must be using the "Centarea HID" in MP, and possibly using...
    Hi, I am at a loss as to what is going on with my installation at the moment. I was using it this morning no problems, shut it...
    Replies
    9
    Views
    1K
    Thanks @CyberSimian! I delved deeper into this issue and especially the "Silent Stream Bug" you mentioned. I downloaded different pieces of software that claimed to do like you said: keeping the DA-convertors "alive" by sending a non-audible signal periodically. Turned out this was NOT the thing happening in my AV-receiver. While...
    Thanks @CyberSimian! I delved deeper into this issue and especially the "Silent Stream Bug" you mentioned. I downloaded different...
    I'm having a strange one here ... it seems to have started after getting a new Sony 4k TV, and manifests itself by refusing to...
    Replies
    9
    Views
    2K
    Hi, must be really a while, cuz I can not remember any post from you ;) But might be also that I joined the team too late. Yes, there will be many things. Main reason is simply, that MP2 is not developed based on MP1. I for example never used MP1. I tried it lately to test voice control and was shocked about many inconsistancies in...
    Hi, must be really a while, cuz I can not remember any post from you ;) But might be also that I joined the team too late. Yes...
    It´s been a while... :) Well, simply the reason is cause MP1 was working so well... :) Now I decided to upgrade my old servers and...
    Replies
    1
    Views
    239
    i don't know if @Owlsroost can look this or @framug
    i don't know if @Owlsroost can look this or @framug
    Hi, I've been using MP TV-Server for ages in and old windows 7 32-bit PC, and different dvb-x cards (t, s). Some months ago I...
    Replies
    2
    Views
    1K
    This is not possible if it is a self made series, like personal travel videos etc.
    This is not possible if it is a self made series, like personal travel videos etc.
    Hi! I have videos that I want to show in TV-Series, such as personal TV series and educational series. As some examples I have...
    Replies
    8
    Views
    935
    Top Bottom