[Rejected] Possible fix for Mantis #0002437 - Incompatibility between HDTV and Microsoft DTV-DVD (1 Viewer)

[te3hpurp]

Well although these fixes issue with Microsoft DTV-DVD it breaks any other HD(dxva) codec in xp, except Coreavc, and maybe divxHD(i have not tried). None of my Cyberlink H264 codecs(technotrend ver(7) i guess, 8 & 9) work anymore in xp with live-tv HD.They have freezing images every 3 sec and gui is in "sync" with those freezes.

Please post a TsReader, MP & vmr9 / evr logs. If you get some sort of picture then it shouldn't be an issue with the video output pins properties.

Ookay,

i'll be back in the evening......

regards,

 

[te3hpurp]

Here are logs from xp machine

So In logs there is tryouts with Cyberlink 8 & 9 codecs(won't work), Coreavc(ok),DivxH264(ok but no deinterlace),archsoft(no picture), MPC(wont'play)


Symptoms are exactly same as in win7 with HD before this fix. Strange.

edit: Just looked logs, and it seems that HW acc is not working, with this fix with Cyberlink....

regards,

 

[tourettes]

So In logs there is tryouts with Cyberlink 8 & 9 codecs(won't work), Coreavc(ok),DivxH264(ok but no deinterlace),archsoft(no picture), MPC(wont'play)

MPC-HC H.264 codec is something that shouldn't even work (as we aren't able to feed correct type of stream from TsReader).

Symptoms are exactly same as in win7 with HD before this fix. Strange.

Too bad that I don't have a XP to test with. I have no clue why it would behave differently than Vista / Windows 7 as the codecs are still the same.

Unfortunately TsReader and VMR9 logs are showing only one codec test as they will get overwritten on every time when tv is started. Could you provide logs per codec?

 

[te3hpurp]

Okay, i'll try to collect them tonight, although it's my turn to put kid to sleep, so i might fall asleep myself

regards,

 

[te3hpurp]

new logs

So In logs there is tryouts with Cyberlink 8 & 9 codecs(won't work), Coreavc(ok),DivxH264(ok but no deinterlace),archsoft(no picture), MPC(wont'play)

MPC-HC H.264 codec is something that shouldn't even work (as we aren't able to feed correct type of stream from TsReader).

Symptoms are exactly same as in win7 with HD before this fix. Strange.

Too bad that I don't have a XP to test with. I have no clue why it would behave differently than Vista / Windows 7 as the codecs are still the same.

Unfortunately TsReader and VMR9 logs are showing only one codec test as they will get overwritten on every time when tv is started. Could you provide logs per codec?

Okay. here is logs.

regards

 

[tourettes]

te3hpurp, could you compare the CPU usage with Cynerlink PDVD 8 / 9 codecs and the current and previous TsReader.ax binaries? Maybe Cyberlink's HW decoding is broken when we have changed the output pin properties (I personaly cannot test HW accell).

 

[te3hpurp]

No change in cpu usage. screen caps attached

te3hpurp, could you compare the CPU usage with Cynerlink PDVD 8 / 9 codecs and the current and previous TsReader.ax binaries? Maybe Cyberlink's HW decoding is broken when we have changed the output pin properties (I personaly cannot test HW accell).

regards,

 

[infinite.loop]

Well although these fixes issue with Microsoft DTV-DVD it breaks any other HD(dxva) codec in xp, except Coreavc, and maybe divxHD(i have not tried). None of my Cyberlink H264 codecs(technotrend ver(7) i guess, 8 & 9) work anymore in xp with live-tv HD.They have freezing images every 3 sec and gui is in "sync" with those freezes.

So. If you use coreavc as h.264 codec, then playback is nolonger smooth.
The video/image shortly "freezes" ever 3 seconds and makes the video to appear "stuttering", is that correct?

Because this is exactly what i see besides one other major issue (mpg2=W7 DTV and h.264=coreavc results in broken HD playback, SD still working)
And i also see the stuttering on SD channels when using MPC-MPV.
While using W7-DTV for SD and SD gives very smooth playback.

 

[te3hpurp]

Well although these fixes issue with Microsoft DTV-DVD it breaks any other HD(dxva) codec in xp, except Coreavc, and maybe divxHD(i have not tried). None of my Cyberlink H264 codecs(technotrend ver(7) i guess, 8 & 9) work anymore in xp with live-tv HD.They have freezing images every 3 sec and gui is in "sync" with those freezes.

So. If you use coreavc as h.264 codec, then playback is nolonger smooth.
The video/image shortly "freezes" ever 3 seconds and makes the video to appear "stuttering", is that correct?

Because this is exactly what i see besides one other major issue (mpg2=W7 DTV and h.264=coreavc results in broken HD playback, SD still working)
And i also see the stuttering on SD channels when using MPC-MPV.
While using W7-DTV for SD and SD gives very smooth playback.

In Win7, everything is fine using Microsoft codecs for everything sd,hd,audio.

In Xp HD Coreavc is Okay. HD with Cyberlink with dxva is NOK. SD is Ok.

 

[infinite.loop]

In Win7, everything is fine using Microsoft codecs for everything sd,hd,audio.

In Xp HD Coreavc is Okay. HD with Cyberlink with dxva is NOK. SD is Ok.

I am not intested in WinXP at all at this point. What happens on W7?
Does playback periodically stutter with coreavc/PDVD codecs?