[Finished] Improvements to Live TV playback rate matching - for testing (2 Viewers)

[azzuro]

testing since the start of the week,
none error, the zaaping is good.
the streamingserver is good too, on lost connection.
i don't have any error. and stable ( none crash / none error )

 

[HTPCSourcer]

I'm interested in log files for the fast and slow changes (I need both the client and sever logs, so I can relate what's happening at both ends of the system).

Alright, I'll start wrting down the time of those slow fast channel changes and note the channels involved.

 

[HTPCSourcer]

Hi,

Here are some quick numbers to start with:

17:42 - 8 sec / SWR RP HD (Startup, first channel after switching on)
17:44 - 6 sec / VOX
17:45 - 3 sec / Kabel
17:46 - 6 sec / SyFy HD (encrypted Sky channel)
17:48 - 7 sec / RTL Crime HD (encrypted Sky channel)
17:49 - 8 sec / Sky Krimi (encrypted Sky channel)
17:50 - 4 sec / RTL Television
17:51 - 4 sec / Das Erste HD
17:52 - 5 sec / ZDF HD

While it is clear that encryped channels take more time to be tuned, SyFy HD is tuned comparably fast with 6 sec while others need 7-8 sec. The Standard time for non-encrypted channels seem to be between 3 and 4 sec. It would be great if this can further reduced. The DD Card is set to "Stop" rather than "Pause". I do remember that I had changed this in the past but did not experience any difference.

 

[Owlsroost]

Hi,

Here are some quick numbers to start with:

17:42 - 8 sec / SWR RP HD (Startup, first channel after switching on)
17:44 - 6 sec / VOX
17:45 - 3 sec / Kabel
17:46 - 6 sec / SyFy HD (encrypted Sky channel)
17:48 - 7 sec / RTL Crime HD (encrypted Sky channel)
17:49 - 8 sec / Sky Krimi (encrypted Sky channel)
17:50 - 4 sec / RTL Television
17:51 - 4 sec / Das Erste HD
17:52 - 5 sec / ZDF HD

While it is clear that encryped channels take more time to be tuned, SyFy HD is tuned comparably fast with 6 sec while others need 7-8 sec. The Standard time for non-encrypted channels seem to be between 3 and 4 sec. It would be great if this can further reduced. The DD Card is set to "Stop" rather than "Pause". I do remember that I had changed this in the past but did not experience any difference.

What are the times when using UNC paths (approximately) ?

 

[HTPCSourcer]

Now I am confused. I've not been using UNC paths recently and thought that you were interested in the RTSP files. Would you like the same under UNC?

 

[HTPCSourcer]

Apologies, I misread your question. Please expect UNC results for the same test channels tomorrow.

 

[Owlsroost]

Now I am confused. I've not been using UNC paths recently and thought that you were interested in the RTSP files. Would you like the same under UNC?

Earlier in the thread you said:

Notwithstanding, a channel change time of 7-9 seconds, compared to some 3 seconds under UNC (when switching from encrypted channel A to encrypted channel B), is definitely a long time. Is there a chance to tune settings, e.g. reduce buffer times etc., to reduce the channel switching time?

...so I was interested in how much slower RTSP (with my recent mods) is compared to UNC paths. I can then compare UNC paths versus RTSP and look at where the extra time is being spent. I only have free-to-air SD DVB-T to test with, which has fairly fast zapping times anyway.

Basically I'm trying to speed up RTSP zapping - if possible - so that (ideally) it's almost as fast as when using UNC paths. I'm not trying to speed up zapping generally i.e. for single-seat and UNC paths - I've spent quite a lot of time on that in the past, and I don't think there is much scope for improving it.

 

[azzuro]

For me it's random; like HTPCsourcer delay chrono, but its better than before.

 

[HTPCSourcer]

Hi,

I switched the same client to UNC and repeated the small test from above. Numbers in parenthesis are from yesterday's RTSP test.

5 sec (8) / SWR RP HD (Startup, first channel after switching on)
3 sec (6) / VOX
2 sec (3) / Kabel
6 sec (6) / SyFy HD (encrypted Sky channel)
6 sec (7) / RTL Crime HD (encrypted Sky channel)
5 sec (8) / Sky Krimi (encrypted Sky channel)
3 sec (4) / RTL Television
4 sec (4) / Das Erste HD
3 sec (5) / ZDF HD

 

[mm1352000]

@HTPCSourcer
Just as a matter of interest, how are you measuring the timing?
(In other words, what are your start and stop flags?)

I suppose client + server log files for the UNC case may also be useful for highlighting differences.