MediaPortal Audio Renderer setup - difference between 5.1 and 5.1 surround? (1 Viewer)

emphatic

Design Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • August 25, 2006
    3,602
    1,093
    Alingsås
    Sweden Sweden
    Country flag
    • Thread starter
    • Moderator
    • #1
    I've noticed recently that some voice dialog are missing (I see subtitles but hear nothing) when I watch media with Dolby Digital or DTS audio. If I bitstream the same stuff I hear the full dialog, so I guess there's something up with the speaker setup? In the MediaPortal Audio Renderer's setup, I can choose "5.1" or "5.1 (Surround)", what's the difference?

    Emph
     

    maiky

    MP Donator
  • Premium Supporter
  • August 3, 2008
    70
    2
    Sweden Sweden
    Try run som audio test movie "this is the left channel..." etc. Then you can try some different settings! But to answer your question, I have no Idea what the difference is :-(
     

    midasxxl

    Portal Pro
    March 22, 2006
    53
    2
    39
    England England
    I always asked it myself, too. Either a strem is 5.1 or not. Sorround sound in its own sense is 4 channel or more
     

    HTPCSourcer

    Retired Team Member
  • Premium Supporter
  • May 16, 2008
    11,431
    2,334
    Germany Germany
    Country flag
    The difference is that 5.1 Surround is supposed to play the hall effects (back speakers)
     

    breese

    Retired Team Member
  • Premium Supporter
  • July 11, 2011
    3,903
    769
    62
    Arlington Heights, Illinois
    United States of America United States of America
    Country flag
    I use a number of different movies and music to test my audio system.
    One of the best is either version of the movie Fantasia. Makes great use of all channels.
    Also depending on the Amp being used (if one), most within the last 8 to 10 years have built in channel tests allowing for each channel and sub to be tested for volume and other settings.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5.1_surround_sound
    5.1 ("five point one") is the common name for six channel surround sound multichannel audio systems.
    All 5.1 systems use the same speaker channels and configuration, having a front left and right, a center channel, two surround channels and a subwoofer.

    Regarding music, the main goal of 5.1 surround sound is a proper localization and equability of all acoustic sources for a centered positioned audience. Therefore ideally five matched speakers should be used.

    • five speakers of the same size for front, center and surround
    • identical distance from the listeners for all five speakers
    • angle adjustment regarding viewing direction of audience: center 0°, front ±22.5° for movies ±30° for music, surround ±110°
     

    emphatic

    Design Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • August 25, 2006
    3,602
    1,093
    Alingsås
    Sweden Sweden
    Country flag
    • Thread starter
    • Moderator
    • #6
    The difference is that 5.1 Surround is supposed to play the hall effects (back speakers)
    So you're saying that "5.1" is only using center (, sub woofer if available) and front speakers, while "5.1 surround" uses all connected speakers? If true, that is just silly.

    Emph
     

    breese

    Retired Team Member
  • Premium Supporter
  • July 11, 2011
    3,903
    769
    62
    Arlington Heights, Illinois
    United States of America United States of America
    Country flag
    In a properly setup audio system (assuming the audio being played is in fact 5.1) the voices will move to the loaction of the people. In a Stereo (2 speaker setup and depending on the age of the music) the song should be ballanced between them. As a test there are a few older Beatle songs where they played with the audio. On a few of them the singer would come up on the left or right channel (I dont remember what song)
    Most Movies (while actors are on screen) will have the voices in the center channel, audio near or behind them from the Left and Right, and other sounds from the rear channel
    The Sub is limted to Base only. A good system will seperate the lower Freq thru the Base (sub) to get the greatest affects.

    My uncle worked as a projectionist in the union here in Chicago for over 40 years. We use to build and rebuild audio systems.

    EDIT: One of the greatest Stereo songs ever done was Free Bird.... If you really want to hear it in its glory and know what to listen for, get the Long version (recorderd in Alanta GA) and listen to the guitars the 2nd half... OMG it is Great!
     

    HTPCSourcer

    Retired Team Member
  • Premium Supporter
  • May 16, 2008
    11,431
    2,334
    Germany Germany
    Country flag
    So you're saying that "5.1" is only using center (, sub woofer if available) and front speakers, while "5.1 surround" uses all connected speakers? If true, that is just silly.
    No, that's not what I mean. Both will use all speakers, but 'Surround' will simply add some effects.

    In your case the trouble with the system is the translation of the encoded DTS system to the analogue 5.1 setup. The respective handling is best done by the amplifier, instead of having Windows audio drivers take care of this. The latter is prone to trouble of your kind and can have different causes, ranging from inappropriate options to driver incompatibilities. IN essence why bother with using analogue decoding if you can have digital, unchanged signaling?
     

    breese

    Retired Team Member
  • Premium Supporter
  • July 11, 2011
    3,903
    769
    62
    Arlington Heights, Illinois
    United States of America United States of America
    Country flag
    What is the connection between your MediaPortal box and Amp?
    I see you have a Dell. Depending on the model, there are a lot of them that have Optical connections. The cable is Cheep and gives the Amp the raw signal to deal with...
    I prefer this on my systems....
     

    emphatic

    Design Group
  • Team MediaPortal
  • August 25, 2006
    3,602
    1,093
    Alingsås
    Sweden Sweden
    Country flag
    • Thread starter
    • Moderator
    • #10
    No, that's not what I mean. Both will use all speakers, but 'Surround' will simply add some effects.

    In your case the trouble with the system is the translation of the encoded DTS system to the analogue 5.1 setup. The respective handling is best done by the amplifier, instead of having Windows audio drivers take care of this. The latter is prone to trouble of your kind and can have different causes, ranging from inappropriate options to driver incompatibilities. IN essence why bother with using analogue decoding if you can have digital, unchanged signaling?
    Sorry if this sounds harsh, but as stated in my System setup, I use HDMI (NVIDIA HD Audio) to my Sony AVR (currently, it used to be a Pioneer AVR using the same computer setup), so I don't understand why you'd think I was feeding my speakers some type of analogue audio. Did you read and fully understand my question in the original post?

    I know what 5.1 and 7.1 sound is, DTS-EX etc, my question was about why the MediaPortal Audio Renderer, and it's vague descriptions...

    Emph
     

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Similar threads
    OP Title Forum Replies Date
    G Anyone else having issues with MC2XML? (not a Mediaportal issue) General Support 3
    A MediaPortal crash (and restart) on LiveTV after Windows Update (Sep 2020) driver update for Intel HD Graphics 4600 General Support 7
    A VideoDatabaseV5.db3 lock not released on shutting down PC from MediaPortal Installation, configuration support 0
    ajs [News] MediaPortal 1.26 Pre-Release ready for testing! News and Announcements 0
    F MediaPortal 1.16 server crashing due to user error? General Support 5
    M Add Radio channels and EPG to Mediaportal xmlTV 2
    Symphy Version 0.2.9.0 for MediaPortal 1.25 ASIO music player 0
    doskabouter Installing mediaportal MediaPortal 1 3
    A Mediaportal Allgemeines Support- und Diskussionsforum 0
    G Update von MediaPortal Installationsprobleme? 0
    ajs [News] MediaPortal 1 - 1.25 Released! News and Announcements 1
    horned_reaper Standby is prevented by MediaPortal client General Support 0
    U [solved] MediaPortal crashing on startup General Support 10
    g0rsq Info box randomly popping up when watching TV or other video MediaPortal 2 Newcomers Forum 1
    high [unanswered] Hallo möchte gerne Mediaportal. nutzen kann mich jemand anrufen? contactform feedback and requests 2
    ajs [News] MediaPortal 1.25 Pre-Release ready for testing! News and Announcements 0
    ajs [Rejected] Mediaportal Codename MediaPortal 1 48
    M 2nd (Touch-)Display Support on MediaPortal 2 such MPDisplay++? General 2
    N Steam release of MediaPortal MediaPortal 1 Talk 0
    torone Dritter versuch mit Mediaportal 2 Allgemeines Support- und Diskussionsforum 1
    M Fehlerhafter Link auf der aktuellen MediaPortal Seite Page- und Forumsfeedback 0
    H 1.24.0 MP 1.24 high CPU utilization when 'Keep MediaPortal always on top' option enabled Bugreports 4
    mickb [solved] Mediaportal Stops working General Support 5
    J [solved] Newbie to MediaPortal 2 - Cannot open/run TV programs Newcomers Forum 4
    atlantic How to use Spotify inside Mediaportal? Listen Music 18

    Similar threads

    Top Bottom