[fixed] [MP2-813] Album artist filter wrong display (4 Viewers)

[henso]

Taglib SHarp can handle Album Artists without any Problems.

The discussion started with issues with the Artist being used instead Album Artist. When investigating that another issue was found: Picard tags the track artists in two different tags: Artist and Artists and. Artist contains only the name of the main artist while Artists contains multiple artists. The MusicBrainzArtistId tag then contains multiple ID's in the same order as in the Artists tag. From what I can see only the Artist tag is read by Taglib. So for Tiglib to support this multiple artists would need to be put in the Artist tag instead. Can you confirm this? See my screenshot in post 25 for more information.

 

[henso]

the origin of this thread was, the albumartist sort view is not respected on MP Client, it seems use artist node instead of albumartists

I think I found an issue where the artist tag was used for finding album artists. I will push a fix to the MP 2.2.3 branch. @HTPCSourcer maybe we should change the thread prefix?

 

[HTPCSourcer]

maybe we should change the thread prefix?

If you think it is a bug then this one changes to “fixed”. But more importantly we need to reopen the Jira.

Also there is no WiP 2.2.3 in Teamcity. @morpheus_xx wanted to create one.

 

[hwahrmann]

The discussion started with issues with the Artist being used instead Album Artist. When investigating that another issue was found: Picard tags the track artists in two different tags: Artist and Artists and. Artist contains only the name of the main artist while Artists contains multiple artists. The MusicBrainzArtistId tag then contains multiple ID's in the same order as in the Artists tag. From what I can see only the Artist tag is read by Taglib. So for Tiglib to support this multiple artists would need to be put in the Artist tag instead. Can you confirm this? See my screenshot in post 25 for more information.

Well there is nothing like "Artists" in the ID3 Standard.
This is a user defined tag, which seems to be created by Picard.
If someone posts a sample file, i would have a look how it is tagged.

 

[henso]

If someone posts a sample file, i would have a look how it is tagged.

@azzuro Could you share the files again?

 

[azzuro]

@azzuro Could you share the files again?

Done to @hwahrmann directly in PM

 

[hwahrmann]

ok, like i suspected. The file is full of "TXXX" frames, which seems to have been added by Picard

And the standard TPE1 and TPE2 fields contain the Artist and AlbumArtist:

 

[henso]

The file is full of "TXXX" frames, which seems to have been added by Picard

So, in conclusion these are not supported by TagLib because they are not standard tags?

 

[azzuro]

@henso
i try the latest commit from WIP2.3 , and i have always issue to show albumartist view.
For me, nothing related to Picard or %artists% tag, MP don't show the albumartist value ... , but show %artist% value when Musicbrainz_AristsTag is different than other files. when track are "featured someone".

 

[henso]

i try the latest commit from WIP2.3 , and i have always issue to show albumartist view.

You need to re-import audio share (remove share and add it again), did you do that?