Recommended HDD! (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Peter2
- Start date
- April 5, 2009
- 245
- 16
- Home Country
-
United States of America
Glad you like your new drive it is getting some great reviews on Newegg. I ended up with the WD black and it is a great drive, very fast and less power then the 250GB WD it replaced, but slightly more audible then I would like for a HTPC.
I would vote for the WD green 1TB WD10EADS but looks like WD just upped the buffer to 64MB and changed the part # again..Oh ya and of course that 4k sector change too...
1TB Hard Disk Drives Roundup: 14 Solutions Reviewed (page 22) - X-bit labs"The WD Green Power WD10EADS will be the best and only choice for a quiet and cold home multimedia center."
I would vote for the WD green 1TB WD10EADS but looks like WD just upped the buffer to 64MB and changed the part # again..Oh ya and of course that 4k sector change too...
1TB Hard Disk Drives Roundup: 14 Solutions Reviewed (page 22) - X-bit labs"The WD Green Power WD10EADS will be the best and only choice for a quiet and cold home multimedia center."
Really not liking Samsung drives at the moment.
I have three 1.5TB F2s that I need to run a full diagnostics on as they drop from both my RAID cards and the motherboard randomly. I also have a 500GB 2.5" Samsung that Windows 7 is warning me about on my netbook. Really not happy with them at all.
On the other hand the four 1.5TB WE EADS drives I have are running perfectly in RAID-5, very quiet too.
I have three 1.5TB F2s that I need to run a full diagnostics on as they drop from both my RAID cards and the motherboard randomly. I also have a 500GB 2.5" Samsung that Windows 7 is warning me about on my netbook. Really not happy with them at all.
On the other hand the four 1.5TB WE EADS drives I have are running perfectly in RAID-5, very quiet too.
- September 18, 2006
- 847
- 53
- Home Country
-
Belgium
- Thread starter
- #4
Well I guess we all don't like a certain brand/type of disc after having issues with it but aren't you comparing apples with pears; spinpoint F2 <-> F3 and wasn't that a known problem: raid with F2?
Even though things like raid become more mainstream, it's really a matter of doing some research yourself before changing hardware.
Even though things like raid become more mainstream, it's really a matter of doing some research yourself before changing hardware.
Hi, here are my thoughts.
Brand does not matter as match when you run Raid or some equivelent but certain things will always be important.
Most manufactures are now going with a 3 year replacement warranty. I use to use Seagate simply because they had a 5 year warranty. It would be interesting to see how this has effected their business. Any way....
I now run 8 1.5 TB Western Digital Greens and am so happy. They have everything that is important for this application:
1. Allot of Space
2. Price versus Space is very good
3. Green version uses less power so you can save on power supply (I run 8 of these, 2 160gb drives, DVD-Rom, IMon Display, 8 Fans, 5 TV-Cards and 8500gt Graphics card on a RaidMAX 700w power supply)
4. Very Quiet!!! With the fans at low speed the entire system is quieter than my old watercooling.
5. Run Cool
6. 64mb buffer has radically increased the read times comparred to the old 32mb drive.
7. Reliable as all hell.
Over and above this is my biggest tip. Get the quickest drive you can afford for a primary drive. For your shared folders think about how much space you think youll need and double it at least. Buy the biggest drive you can afford even if it means that you have to put off purchaing for a while. I have spent more money upgrading harddrives than possibly petrol in a year.
Reading over this entry I realise that I have not really answered your question but hopefully it will allow you to make a better decision when the time comes.
Cheers
Brand does not matter as match when you run Raid or some equivelent but certain things will always be important.
Most manufactures are now going with a 3 year replacement warranty. I use to use Seagate simply because they had a 5 year warranty. It would be interesting to see how this has effected their business. Any way....
I now run 8 1.5 TB Western Digital Greens and am so happy. They have everything that is important for this application:
1. Allot of Space
2. Price versus Space is very good
3. Green version uses less power so you can save on power supply (I run 8 of these, 2 160gb drives, DVD-Rom, IMon Display, 8 Fans, 5 TV-Cards and 8500gt Graphics card on a RaidMAX 700w power supply)
4. Very Quiet!!! With the fans at low speed the entire system is quieter than my old watercooling.
5. Run Cool
6. 64mb buffer has radically increased the read times comparred to the old 32mb drive.
7. Reliable as all hell.
Over and above this is my biggest tip. Get the quickest drive you can afford for a primary drive. For your shared folders think about how much space you think youll need and double it at least. Buy the biggest drive you can afford even if it means that you have to put off purchaing for a while. I have spent more money upgrading harddrives than possibly petrol in a year.
Reading over this entry I realise that I have not really answered your question but hopefully it will allow you to make a better decision when the time comes.
Cheers
Users who are viewing this thread
Similar threads
Hi CyberSimian (and others) just a bit along the coast from me (near Exeter) - I know you are very long-standing!
Not going to make this long winded or anything, but just to point out over the @15 years I've overall donated several hundred quid. And I begrduge NONE of it, not a penny - I do wish MP well - 100%. It is an awesome...
Hi CyberSimian (and others) just a bit along the coast from me (near Exeter) - I know you are very long-standing!
Not going to...
ONGGGG term MP user (and donator - why wouldn't you?) and leaving somewhat reluctantly. Few reasons, some that just seem...
Hi there,
since I changed TV and HTPC's CPU, I'm wondering if this guide:
Guide
could be considered still good today, since it's been almost 13 years since then and it's still referring to a resolution of 1080p?
I say this because I have a new Panasonic 4K HDR TV, and with that settings, even if I have an old Gygabyte GPU (bought...
Hi there,
since I changed TV and HTPC's CPU, I'm wondering if this guide:
Guide
could be considered still good today, since it's...
Hi there,
since I changed TV and HTPC's CPU, I'm wondering if this guide:
Guide
could be considered still good today, since it's...
two simultaneous recordings succeeded. All good!
two simultaneous recordings succeeded. All good!
Since upgrading from 1.36 to 1.38, MP1 no longer connects to my tuners. They no longer appear under the server in the left-hand...
For music you may use -->
https://www.team-mediaportal.de/erweiterungen/musik/global-search
With GlobalSearch you can search for any entry in your music database: Artist, Album, Title, Lyrics...
I'm afraid there is no such plugin :unsure:
For music you may use -->
https://www.team-mediaportal.de/erweiterungen/musik/global-search
With GlobalSearch you can search for...
HI,
I'm new to MediaPortal and have a question about searching for data. I have an extensive collection of music, films, and TV...
Ran into this problem following an otherwise sucessful upgrade from MP 1.34 x64 to MP 1.35 x64 the CEC Remote plugin which I use just to control volume and standby, will no longer put my devices (TV & AVR) to sleep when the HTPC is put in standby. Also when I wake up the HTPC MP closes or crashes (not sure which) as per the example in...
Ran into this problem following an otherwise sucessful upgrade from MP 1.34 x64 to MP 1.35 x64 the CEC Remote plugin which I use...
Ran into this problem following an otherwise sucessful upgrade from MP 1.34 x64 to MP 1.35 x64 the CEC Remote plugin which I use...