SOLVED VC-1 issues (VC1) (2 Viewers)

[Kotik]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

So,

Sebastiii's Gabest MpegSplitter is working perfectly. Thanx Sebastiii.

nevcairiel

Still no go

On my sample, that is 29.970 Interlaced VC-1 i am getting 40fps at some scenes and then 60fps on some others. If you need a bigger sample pls do ask for it and i will upload it.

I really want to switch to LAV atm but this VC-1i issue is preventing me.

 

[domb]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

So,

Sebastiii's Gabest MpegSplitter is working perfectly. Thanx Sebastiii.

@Nevcairiel

Still no go

On my sample, that is 29.970 Interlaced VC-1 i am getting 40fps at some scenes and then 60fps on some others. If you need a bigger sample pls do ask for it and i will upload it.

I really want to switch to LAV atm but this VC-1i issue is preventing me.

Why do you want to switch if you have a working solution? Whats the benefit of using LAV?

 

[nevcairiel]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

@Nevcairiel

Still no go

On my sample, that is 29.970 Interlaced VC-1 i am getting 40fps at some scenes and then 60fps on some others. If you need a bigger sample pls do ask for it and i will upload it.

Weird. The two samples i tried seem to drop around 30 frames at the beginning, but after that it seems to be running smoothly at the target framerate. That is your and hoborgs samples from the last page.

The overall problem is that ffmpeg does not support interlaced VC-1, not even reading the stream header, thats why i don't get any information about the frames, and cannot trust any values it gives me. (It assumes every packet is a new frame, but instead they are just fields, which probably results in the broken timestamps)

I have another test built for you.

http://files.1f0.de/lavf/LAVSplitter-0.17-vc1-test2.zip

I disabled all timestamp processing and parsing in ffmpeg, which should output the frames as they are in the file (basically how the mpc-hc splitter works).
I dumped the output to a file, and the timestamps were practically identical to the mpc-hc splitter.

Please report if it works for you. =)

 

[domb]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

Hi

Can you try this one
Seb

Bingo!
Now it is working with PDVD - enabled/disabled DxVA and with perfect timestamps !

How do you enable DXVA with PowerDVD codec? I open the settings using GraphEdit but it always switches back to software?

 

[hoborg]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

How do you enable DXVA with PowerDVD codec? I open the settings using GraphEdit but it always switches back to software?

It simply working for me (SAF5).

 

[Sebastiii]

Hi,

I enable ffdshow audio, and when i play it, ffdshow is in systray and we can select cyberlink by right click on it and here we can enable DXVA
We can also edit registry to set the correct value, i didn't have in mind but i think i can find it
Seb.

 

[Sebastiii]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

@Nevcairiel

Still no go

On my sample, that is 29.970 Interlaced VC-1 i am getting 40fps at some scenes and then 60fps on some others. If you need a bigger sample pls do ask for it and i will upload it.

Weird. The two samples i tried seem to drop around 30 frames at the beginning, but after that it seems to be running smoothly at the target framerate. That is your and hoborgs samples from the last page.

The overall problem is that ffmpeg does not support interlaced VC-1, not even reading the stream header, thats why i don't get any information about the frames, and cannot trust any values it gives me. (It assumes every packet is a new frame, but instead they are just fields, which probably results in the broken timestamps)

I have another test built for you.

http://files.1f0.de/lavf/LAVSplitter-0.17-vc1-test2.zip

I disabled all timestamp processing and parsing in ffmpeg, which should output the frames as they are in the file (basically how the mpc-hc splitter works).
I dumped the output to a file, and the timestamps were practically identical to the mpc-hc splitter.

Please report if it works for you. =)

Nice, i can't test for now but i hope that is working
Seb.

 

[Kotik]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

Please report if it works for you. =)

The last version DOES work

Gratz and thanx.

Why do you want to switch if you have a working solution? Whats the benefit of using LAV?

LAV is a splitter that has constant development and i like it's all in one splitter approach.

Plus, nevcairiel (LAV dev) is someone that you can get in touch with.

MPC-HC dev team announced that when LAV is stable enough they will replace all the Gabest splitters with LAV. So the way i see it LAV is the way to go today So i am willing to try it and give feedback.

 

[nevcairiel]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

The last version DOES work

Gratz and thanx.

Great! I will create some options and logic around that then, and officially add it in 0.18

 

[domb]

Re: VC-1 issues (VC1)

I'm not a dev but i try lol
Can you try this one for Matroska Splitter, it should work now.
Thanks,
Seb.

sorry I meant for haali splitter for MKVs

Hi,

I enable ffdshow audio, and when i play it, ffdshow is in systray and we can select cyberlink by right click on it and here we can enable DXVA
We can also edit registry to set the correct value, i didn't have in mind but i think i can find it
Seb.

I never saw the decoders were listed in ffdshow menu! i checked and its on cheers.

hoborg stop telling me to use SAF! I don't want to and you're not being helpful.