[no Bug] Subtitle Issues (.m2ts .mkv) MPC Splitter Matroska and Mpeg. (1 Viewer)

[rivera]

I dowloaded RC2 and checked whether subs in m2ts work or don't.
No success .
Then I replaced with fresh mpcSubs.dll.
Then it started working BUT.....

Before:
Since I unchecked "Autoload subtitles" checkbox in Configuration - at
playback I do not see subs initially.
If I press an appropriate hotkey to switch subs then I see subs #1.
After next switch I see subs #2.
Next - no subs again. (So far it works fine).
If I switch again - I do not see subs (although it is indicated in OSD that
subs #1 are ON).

Now:
I do not see subs initially.
If I press an appropriate hotkey to switch subs then I see subs #1.
After next switch I see subs #2.
Next - no subs again. (So far it works fine).
If I switch again - I can see subs - but they can be #1 or #2 erratically. Also they can be switched from one to another by themself

 

[cpp2005]

Thanks Sebastiii and rivera.
Please compare your results with MPC-HC because when I say "working ok" it means as in MPC-HC, not that it's bug free.
rivera can you upload the sample? With your test3 I don't have such behavior.

 

[rivera]

cpp2005
In MPC-HC with internal Gabest splitter I do not observe any errors - it works flawless IMHO.

Regarding sample - "Batman Begins":
RapidShare: 1-CLICK Web hosting - Easy Filehosting
Duration 1 minute, it has 3 subs.

 

[Sebastiii]

Hi,

I have made a backup : Sample test4.rar

Thx,
Seb.

 

[rivera]

so, any test were performed with my sample ?

 

[cpp2005]

Hi rivera,
I checked it and don't have issues like you said. Sebastiii can you check it too?
What I noted that it takes few seconds to subtitle to change but it also happens in MPC-HC.
Can you verify that you are using the same playback configuration in Mediaportal and in MPC-HC, using graphedit or graphstudio?

 

[rivera]

cpp2005
I am absolutely sure - except in renderer.
According to GraphEdit, I have absolutely same chain that in MPC-HC .
Probably, renderers are different. But it cannot affect the problem.

cpp2005, which MpegSplitter do you use exactly? How did you register it?

 

[Sebastiii]

Hi, i'll made test today and report it
Thanks,
Seb.

 

[Sebastiii]

Hi,

So i have made some test on my HTPC, RC2 (last SVN and last DLL mpcSubs.dll).

I start in myvideo :
I checked "Autoload subtitles" to see what happen.

1 - First sub in Russian (autoload)
2 - go to english (always Russian, i have to wait some second or rewind 5 sec)
3 - go 3/3 subs (i have to wait some second or rewind 5 sec)
4 - Select OFF (no subs)
5 - Russian (i see english for some second if i want to see directly 5 sec rewind)

So it seems that is working better here.

This is my test with unchecked "Autoload subtitles" checkbox in Configuration :

1 - First select sub in Russian (i have to wait some second or rewind 5 sec and sometimes appear directly)
2 - go to english (always Russian, i have to wait some second or rewind 5 sec)
3 - go 3/3 subs (i have to wait some second or rewind 5 sec)
4 - Select OFF (no subs)
5 - select sub Russian (i see english for some second if i want to see directly 5 sec rewind)

But sometime, i must wait long time many second to sub appear (i can force more quickly by rewind 5 second when sub it supposed to be here).

I have tested in graphstudio, MPC-HC and MP, i have the same result
I have also tested with FFDShow (subtitle fonction thank Albain) and i have the same result too.
I attach my mpegsplitter.ax enjoy

Cheers,
Seb.

 

[rivera]

5 - Russian (i see english for some second if i want to see directly 5 sec rewind)

Well, I see the same - english subs are displayed insted of russian.

I have tested in graphstudio, MPC-HC and MP, i have the same result

In MPC-HC subs are displayed correctly (unlike described above) but with some delay too, and may be the delay is a little bit smaller.