devo said:...
I like the idea but I have two concerns:
1) We would be changing the way every web browser works, ie the toolbar at the top. This would not be good from a usability perspective.
2) Width, yes true 16:9 tvs are gaining more popularity but I belive with options to autohide the toolbar at the top and status bar at the bottom that we would have the full screen for browsing.
Regarding (1) and the usability perspective. Since this is a HTPC and the main usability will (probably) be through remote control - or so is the goal of most people with a HTPC, usability is what is expected from a new user control and if it is designed well then normal use shouldn't have any issues. Look at WebTV (now MSNTV) browser - they had gone through ALOT of user studies. Now before anyone starts talking about MS and the evil empire - this group was WebTV before they got bought by Microsoft and had alot of good minds developing this product and it is still a good product for seniors with no PC experience needed. And we can still learn from the UI which they developed for use on TV.
...But if this had been a replacement for a browser to be used in a PC then I would agree with your statement.
Mike