methods of using TV server - discussion thread (2 Viewers)

pangel

Portal Pro
February 5, 2005
52
0
Denmark
Will there be support for DVB-subtitles and Teletext-subtitles in the initial version?

/pangel
 

yuvalt

New Member
October 7, 2006
2
0
Home Country
Israel Israel
Support XBMC as a client!

I think that the most important thing for me is that the protocol between the client and server will be well documented so I can help in porting the code to the XBOX Media Center....

Excellent news, guys, good luck!
 

Gamester17

Portal Pro
May 12, 2004
98
3
Sweden
Home Country
Sweden Sweden
Will the client be ablle to run on a 1 or 2GB IDE Flash Storage -DiskOnModule.
No HDD at all in the system just an Flash IDE Drive.
Good question!, I'm curious about that as well, as I have a very small fanless (VIA EPIA MINI-ITX based) PC that (though I haven't tried it) can boot directly from a USB-key, so I don't even need a CompactFlash to IDE/ATA converter, and I got a USB 2.0 PCI-adapter in it which has an internal USB-connector too so can just connect the USB-stick inside the computer via that.

However I'm not sure one can fit both the Windows XP Home-Edition or Professional-Edition (or 2003 Server) operating-system and MediaPortal on just 1GB (or 2GB), even with the virtual-memory page-file disabled in windows, (plus I'm not sure how well Windows and MediaPortal run without a virtual-memory). Best would probebly be if one could install and run MediaPortal on Windows XP Embedded or Windows CE 6.0 (with the .NET Compact Framework 2.0) as those have a much smaller footprint for the Windows operating-system.

Speaking about Windows CE 6.0 and the .NET Compact Framework 2.0. Does MediaPortal support the .NET Compact Framework 2.0 and run on Windows CE 6.0?, have anyone tried it? .NET Compact Framework 2.0 is not exacly the same as the normal .NET Framework 2.0, they both do the same thing but the .NET Compact Framework 2.0 doesn't have all the libraries/classes that the full .NET Framework 2.0 so MediaPortal code might have to altered just a bit to support both.

Now Windows Operating-Systems usually only run on x86 processor/hardware-platforms, however a other cool thing about Windows CE 6.0 is that it supports ARM, MIPS and SH4 processors/platforms as well. Though Windows CE 6.0 does not support as many device drivers as Windows XP and Windows XP Embedded does (which both supports the same device drivers), and Windows CE 6.0 does only support the .NET Compact Framework 2.0, (while Windows XP and Windows XP Embedded both support the full standard NET Framework 2.0), but is so happens that the .NET Compact Framework 2.0 is the same .NET Compact Framework 2.0 that will run on the Xbox360 when the XNA Framework for Xbox360 is released by Microsoft in December this year, (thus also making it possible to port MediaPortal to the Xbox360 when the XNA for it comes out).
 

Frodo

Retired Team Member
  • Premium Supporter
  • April 22, 2004
    1,518
    121
    53
    The Netherlands
    Home Country
    Netherlands Netherlands
    will there be:
    >DVB-subtitles and Teletext-subtitles ?
    don't think so, planned for a later release.
    You can watch Teletext pages, but subtitling. not yet

    >Placeshifting?
    yes

    >Whats the protocol?
    For streaming RTSP (mpeg-2 transport stream)
    For controlling the tv server : via .net remoting.
    which is implemented in a seperate dll you can use.

    Frodo
     

    joboehl

    Retired Team Member
  • Premium Supporter
  • July 30, 2006
    431
    4
    Home Country
    Brazil Brazil
    The first version won't have plugin support, however this will be added soon after the release.

    Frodo

    Frodo, first of all, great work !!!

    Just want to understand what you mean about first version. You mean the first SVN released version of the first final version, will not have plug-in support?

    I don't know how the team plans to roll out the server engine (svns, beta, final releases) and etc.

    Julio
     

    samuel337

    Portal Pro
    August 25, 2004
    772
    0
    Melbourne, Australia
    Good question!, I'm curious about that as well, as I have a very small fanless (VIA EPIA MINI-ITX based) PC that (though I haven't tried it) can boot directly from a USB-key, so I don't even need a CompactFlash to IDE/ATA converter, and I got a USB 2.0 PCI-adapter in it which has an internal USB-connector too so can just connect the USB-stick inside the computer via that.

    However I'm not sure one can fit both the Windows XP Home-Edition or Professional-Edition (or 2003 Server) operating-system and MediaPortal on just 1GB (or 2GB), even with the virtual-memory page-file disabled in windows, (plus I'm not sure how well Windows and MediaPortal run without a virtual-memory). Best would probebly be if one could install and run MediaPortal on Windows XP Embedded or Windows CE 6.0 (with the .NET Compact Framework 2.0) as those have a much smaller footprint for the Windows operating-system.

    Speaking about Windows CE 6.0 and the .NET Compact Framework 2.0. Does MediaPortal support the .NET Compact Framework 2.0 and run on Windows CE 6.0?, have anyone tried it? .NET Compact Framework 2.0 is not exacly the same as the normal .NET Framework 2.0, they both do the same thing but the .NET Compact Framework 2.0 doesn't have all the libraries/classes that the full .NET Framework 2.0 so MediaPortal code might have to altered just a bit to support both.

    Now Windows Operating-Systems usually only run on x86 processor/hardware-platforms, however a other cool thing about Windows CE 6.0 is that it supports ARM, MIPS and SH4 processors/platforms as well. Though Windows CE 6.0 does not support as many device drivers as Windows XP and Windows XP Embedded does (which both supports the same device drivers), and Windows CE 6.0 does only support the .NET Compact Framework 2.0, (while Windows XP and Windows XP Embedded both support the full standard NET Framework 2.0), but is so happens that the .NET Compact Framework 2.0 is the same .NET Compact Framework 2.0 that will run on the Xbox360 when the XNA Framework for Xbox360 is released by Microsoft in December this year, (thus also making it possible to port MediaPortal to the Xbox360 when the XNA for it comes out).

    Interesting stuff about .NET CF 2.0 on the Xbox 360 - be interested to see what happens... sounds like it'll kick the PS3's arse anyway :D

    Anyway, the problem with .NET CF 2.0 is that I don't think its inline with the MP team's long term goal of moving off direct DirectX manipulation and onto WPF (Windows Presentation Foundation, aka Avalon). AFAIK, there won't be a WPF equivalent in the .NET CF 2.0. The most that will get into .NET CF 2.0 will probably be WPF/E (Windows Presentation Foundation Everywhere), which is the version designed to take on Flash essentially. Problem is, if what I've read is true, the 3D features will be stripped out in that version.

    Best result will be if the MP code is flexible enough to run on both WPF/E or WPF but I think that sounds unlikely.

    Hopefully once Windows Vista Embedded is released, and when we all have flash/HD combination drives, we'll finally have one of the best features of Windows CE - instant on.

    EDIT: I'm not speaking on behalf of the MP devs...just what I gather from reading the forums.

    Sam
     

    DarkWader

    Portal Pro
    October 3, 2006
    270
    6
    46
    Home Country
    Norway Norway
    OMG!! This is just perfectly great..
    Now you ppl are forcing me in buying a new server and some tv-cards >_<

    hehe.. cant wait for it :)
     

    WILU

    Portal Member
    September 12, 2006
    7
    0
    44
    Tychy
    Home Country
    Poland Poland
    I have a quostion: according to the diagram (pdf) tv card should be placed in server. so the question is: do I need one or three tv cards if I have 3 media center computers? sorry for a dumb question but it's not clear for me...
     

    Frodo

    Retired Team Member
  • Premium Supporter
  • April 22, 2004
    1,518
    121
    53
    The Netherlands
    Home Country
    Netherlands Netherlands
    According to the diagram (pdf) tv card should be placed in server. so the question is: do I need one or three tv cards if I have 3 media center computers? sorry for a dumb question but it's not clear for me...

    You can have a tvserver with just 1 card and 1,2,3 or more clients
    All clients can watch tv at the same time.
    However since the server only has 1 tv card they all see the same tv channel.
    Now if you had 3 tvcards in the tvserver, each client could watch a different channel.

    Just want to understand what you mean about first version. You mean the first SVN released version of the first final version, will not have plug-in support?
    The first version which will be made publicly available wont have plugin support yet as said, we'll add it soon after so people can extend the server with various featues

    Will the client be ablle to run on a 1 or 2GB IDE Flash Storage -DiskOnModule.
    No HDD at all in the system just an Flash IDE Drive.
    The only client there is right now is MediaPortal, so if you can run MP on your flash card then the answer is yes.
    Maybe in time other clients will arise, I can imagine other htpc's apps looking at the tvserver as well and it wouldnt surprise me someone is developing a client-plugin for mce 2005, sagetv, ....
    Note, that since the server uses RTSP you can watch streaming tv also in
    VLC and/or mplayer (dunno XBMC, can it play rtsp video streams?)
    However these apps cannot control the tvserver at this moment
    For controlling the tv-server (example zap to another channel) the client should
    either implement the protocol or use the tvcontrol.dll (.net) we supply

    When will it be released?
    As always things take (much) more time then we first thought.
    At this stage we're working on fixing the last issues with streaming.
    Once thats done we'll release it.
    I hope/expect that within a few weeks you will see a release


    Frodo
     

    Users who are viewing this thread

    Top Bottom