I'd be happy if just one volume OSD worked with remote. As i clearly articulated already, the issue is when remote/keyboard volume controls, the volume OSD is absent altogether in MP 1.21 + Windows 7, whereas previously in MP1.20 + Windows 7 -> volume OSD worked.Why do you need two different volume OSDs?
As long as the volume can be controlled by both keyboard and the remote control, and an OSD (of some kind) is displayed, isn't that enough?
I've now tried MP 1.20 on the same Win 7 system.
Using the keyboard - & = keys I see the MP volume OSD (same as 1.21)
Using the keyboard 'volume -' and 'volume +' keys (the ones with speaker icons on them) I see the Windows volume OSD *and* the MP volume OSD (different to 1.21).
@Hazza06 - Is that the same behavior as on your system?
I've installed MP 1.21 on the only PC I have that runs Win 7 (an old Samsung NC110 'netbook').
Using the keyboard - & = keys I see the MP volume OSD.
Using the keyboard 'volume -' and 'volume +' keys (the ones with speaker icons on them) I see the Windows volume OSD (but not the MP volume OSD)
I can't test with an MCE remote as I don't have one.
MP sound settings I used:
View attachment 200521
Done - [MP1-4940] Audio volume control and OSD problems on Windows 7 - MediaPortal JiraCan a regression bug be raised ?
None of those OSD apps work, at least with the MCE RC6 remoteDone - [MP1-4940] Audio volume control and OSD problems on Windows 7 - MediaPortal Jira
Can't say how long it might be until someone can look into it - just depends on when someone has the time (and a Win 7 system to debug it on).
In the meantime, this page lists a few volume OSD apps that might be useful as a workaround - 5 Tools To Get An On Screen Volume Level Indicator • Raymond.CC
|S||Mini Display MP 1.24 no Volume OSD no action for keys||Mini Display||0|
|R||[solved] Hide Windows 10 volume OSD||Feature Requests||3|
|M||1.24.0 Volume Overwrite by Mixer||Bugreports||2|
|R||Normalise sound volume somehow?||Television (MyTV frontend and TV-Server)||5|
|MCE Remote Disable Volume Mapping||Input / Output interfaces||0|
|Erratic volume bars and development ideas||General Support||17|
|J||Media Portal changes master volume level||General Support||7|
|[fixed] Channel number in zap OSD||MediaPortal 1||107|
|H||Live TV info OSD not displaying number of audio channels||General Support||3|