[WiP] madVR support in MP1 (97 Viewers)
- Thread starter Sebastiii
- Start date
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #4,102
Great 
@Kotik
So i will build a new version, it seems that subtitle 3D is better (in size) but only works with MPC-HC Engine, it will not change the behavior for XySubFilter
So based on finding @Kotik i was able to port some code from MPC-BE (thanks to their team) to display the subtitle to SBS or TAB with or without "Position relative to.... option"
We need to use Auto3D plugin
Enjoy
V341 : http://tinyurl.com/y8vxnj5p
@KotikSo i will build a new version, it seems that subtitle 3D is better (in size) but only works with MPC-HC Engine
, it will not change the behavior for XySubFilter So based on finding @Kotik i was able to port some code from MPC-BE (thanks to their team) to display the subtitle to SBS or TAB with or without "Position relative to.... option"
We need to use Auto3D plugin
Enjoy
V341 : http://tinyurl.com/y8vxnj5p
Last edited:
Very nice @Sebastiii
May i ask what is better in XySubFilter compared to MPC-HC? The reason we initially added and ported it was for 3D subtitles support, currently MPC-HC does native 3D MVC and SBS/TAB subs aswell. XySubFilter hasnt been active in development for quite some time.
I would like to hear what others have to say about it. I feel like trying to make both subtitle engine working is taking too much of Sebastiii's time and effort.
If it was up to me i would hear peoples arguments and see if there really is a valid reason to keep both engines supported, keep in mind that i only used XySubFilter for like a month and that was until Sebastiii updated the MPC-HC engine and since then i only use that.
Am i missing something?
May i ask what is better in XySubFilter compared to MPC-HC? The reason we initially added and ported it was for 3D subtitles support, currently MPC-HC does native 3D MVC and SBS/TAB subs aswell. XySubFilter hasnt been active in development for quite some time.
I would like to hear what others have to say about it. I feel like trying to make both subtitle engine working is taking too much of Sebastiii's time and effort.
If it was up to me i would hear peoples arguments and see if there really is a valid reason to keep both engines supported, keep in mind that i only used XySubFilter for like a month and that was until Sebastiii updated the MPC-HC engine and since then i only use that.
Am i missing something?
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #4,104
Hey
I think maybe it's because of direct rendering subs with madVR (so gain ms of rendering) but not sure
On my side i'm using MPC-HC Engine too and discover one week ago that we have an issue (the Delay to sync sub against lips was broken, but it's fixed now).
Fo XySubFilter, i fear that i can't do nothing about it for 3D
Thanks
I think maybe it's because of direct rendering subs with madVR (so gain ms of rendering) but not sure
On my side i'm using MPC-HC Engine too and discover one week ago that we have an issue (the Delay to sync sub against lips was broken, but it's fixed now).
Fo XySubFilter, i fear that i can't do nothing about it for 3D
Thanks
- August 9, 2012
- 2,715
- 2,078
- Home Country
-
Germany
Hi Sebastiii, please would you PM a sample also as I only have one SBS, a complete movie, on my HTPC and it will be a pain to copy it over to my Desktop PC for testing.
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #4,106
Hi
PM sent
Also i did notice that on my HTPC (3D stuff) MVC video is detected as 3D by Auto3D and then like madVR already split the OSD/GUI, Auto3D does split it also, that's not correct, the only way we can do for now and not letting Auto3D detect the stream and then manually switch to the 3D mode we want by Auto3D menu.
In fact we can't relly detect the MVC mode, it's direct madVR / LAV Video and 3D APi.
I was thinking maybe adding a MVC option in context Auto3D menu but it will be a lot of stuff for not really improvement like we can't detect MVC lol.
PM sent
Also i did notice that on my HTPC (3D stuff) MVC video is detected as 3D by Auto3D and then like madVR already split the OSD/GUI, Auto3D does split it also, that's not correct, the only way we can do for now and not letting Auto3D detect the stream and then manually switch to the 3D mode we want by Auto3D menu.
In fact we can't relly detect the MVC mode, it's direct madVR / LAV Video and 3D APi.
I was thinking maybe adding a MVC option in context Auto3D menu but it will be a lot of stuff for not really improvement like we can't detect MVC lol.
Hi @Sebastiii,
thanks for your great effort with madVR. This morning i've found some time for testing the current version. Unfortunately i've noticed the well known old issue, that MP freezes by switching from HD (Das Erste 720p) to SD (RTL). After switching i hear sound of RTL for a second, then playback freezes. Logs are attached.
thanks for your great effort with madVR. This morning i've found some time for testing the current version. Unfortunately i've noticed the well known old issue, that MP freezes by switching from HD (Das Erste 720p) to SD (RTL). After switching i hear sound of RTL for a second, then playback freezes. Logs are attached.
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #4,108
Hi
Yep that's because of "Der Anzeigetreiber igfx" reagiert nicht mehr und wurde wiederhergestellt."
Last time we revert to an older GPU driver to fix this
Can we teamviewer for a quick test ?
Thanks.
You've got pm.
thanks seb,
it seems great on the desktop with the new auto3d mphb(-be) subs:
awesome, sbs doubled great so far and also converted to 2d looks quite nice now
but^^ well, over the years it served me nearly flawlessly and atm i consider it almost the best fall back solution for strange subs with anime and similar in the mean time...sadly it always depends a bit on the damn subtitles used and like always whats personally preferredsee:
and i guess most users remain anyway with mphc and in this context the xysub restriction to use it only with madvr makes synonymous sense to me..
also everyone is now warned thanks to the popup
thats with xysub and 3d subs - seems working like it should
and if i remember right, its because how xy/mad does the scaling. it will use the monitor resolution not to video ones...
so the bad part with new version... auto3d detection is still strange on mixed sbs/tab videos and on tab stuff it wasnt working at all somehow, manually all switch was ok
and fp 3d mvc, auto3d detects it now
doesn't lav flag it 3d api on or something like that?
cheers
it seems great on the desktop with the new auto3d mphb(-be) subs:
awesome, sbs doubled great so far and also converted to 2d looks quite nice now
yep, especially now after your great idea with the mpc-be code port it is now almost no longer necessary.
but^^ well, over the years it served me nearly flawlessly and atm i consider it almost the best fall back solution for strange subs with anime and similar in the mean time...sadly it always depends a bit on the damn subtitles used and like always whats personally preferred
see: and i guess most users remain anyway with mphc and in this context the xysub restriction to use it only with madvr makes synonymous sense to me..
also everyone is now warned thanks to the popup
there is no need to...i hope and guessit will not change the behavior for XySubFilter
thats with xysub and 3d subs - seems working like it should
and if i remember right, its because how xy/mad does the scaling. it will use the monitor resolution not to video ones...
so the bad part with new version... auto3d detection is still strange on mixed sbs/tab videos and on tab stuff it wasnt working at all somehow, manually all switch was ok
and fp 3d mvc, auto3d detects it now
doesn't lav flag it 3d api on or something like that?
cheers